21 meeting chapters across 3:10:58. Select a coloured band to jump to the start of that chapter, or drag the position marker to move through the transcript; light grey means procedural or unassigned dialogue.
Chapter 1 · 1 — WELCOME
About this transcript
This transcript and its speaker attributions may contain errors. Speaker names may be corrected in later releases. Official Council minutes remain authoritative.
I believe this project makes Hawkesbury Council the first Council in Australia to offer the accountability of a searchable meeting transcript.
Welcome everyone to our meeting tonight. Thank you for attending. Before we begin, I would like to outline the standards of conduct that apply to everyone in the chamber this evening. These apply at every meeting and to all attendees, including members of the public and the media. Council meetings are conducted under Council's Code of Meeting Practice. To ensure the meeting runs in an orderly, respectful and safe way, I ask that everyone in the public gallery remain seated in the designated public and media seating areas, refrain from interjecting, calling out or making comments while the meeting is in progress, not approach or attempt to speak with councillors or staff during the meeting unless invited to do so, including during any adjournment, treat councillors, staff and other attendees with courtesy and respect, without intimidating, offensive or threatening behaviour, words or gestures, not record, photograph or live stream the meeting unless expressly permitted by resolution of Council, and follow any direction given by the Chairperson or by Council staff.
Members of the public who are registered to address Council will be invited to speak at the appropriate time. If anyone does not comply with these requirements, I will first ask them to stop. If the behaviour continues or is serious, I may adjourn the meeting and leave the chair. Upon recommencement of the meeting, and if the behaviour continues, in accordance with the Code of Meeting Practice, I may expel that person from the meeting. These expectations are displayed in the public gallery and on Council's website. This evening's meeting is being webcast and recorded. Thank you for your co-operation.
PROC-ACKNOWLEDGEMENTOFINDIGENOUSHERITAGE — b) Acknowledgement of Indigenous Heritage
Mary Lyons-Buckett
Hawkesbury City Council acknowledges the Dharug and Darkinjung people as the traditional custodians of the land of the Hawkesbury. We pay respect to all Elders, past, present and emerging, and acknowledge all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as the First Peoples of the country.
Laurie Mifsud(staff - Director Corporate Services)
Thank you, Madam Mayor. Members of the public who are attending the meeting are advised that in the event of an emergency, you will be asked to proceed in an orderly manner to the nearest exit following the guidance of our warden. I'd also like to advise that in accordance with clause 5.33 of the Code of Meeting Practice, meetings of the Council are recorded. In the terms of the Privacy and Personal Information Protection Act, this may involve the recording of personal information provided at the time of the meeting. The recordings are made to assist staff in compiling the minutes of the meeting and to enable the live stream of Council meetings. The revision of any information that is recorded is voluntary.
If any person does not wish to be recorded, they should not address or request to address the meeting. The gallery can be seen in the live stream video. If you do not wish to be recorded in the live stream, please move to the foyer and we will turn the foyer speakers on for you. The recordings may be available to other persons where such access is in accordance with relevant regulations. The recordings are stored in Council's records management system and uploaded to Council's website. Meetings of Council may be separately recorded with the prior authority of Council. For the benefit of those persons who will be addressing the public forum tonight, it is expected that you will refrain from making any insult, allegation or personal reflection against any person present or not at this forum.
This request relates to both your address to Council and any answers given in response to questions from councillors. Finally, it is also requested that any person participating in or attending the meeting that has a mobile phone, that they either turn it off or turn it to silent. Thank you.
Thank you, Mr Mifsud. We do acknowledge that tonight we will have the presence, shortly online, of the Audit Office of New South Wales to deliver the annual audit findings.
3 — APOLOGIES AND LEAVE OF ABSENCE OR ATTENDANCE BY AUDIO-VISUAL LINK BY COUNCILLORS
Official meeting record
Council decision and source documents
Outcome: Carried
239 Resolution
RESOLVED on the motion of Councillor Wheeler, seconded by Councillor Reardon that the apologies tendered by Councillor Eddie Dogramaci and Councillor Mike Creed for the Council Meeting of 17 November 2026 be accepted.
We have two apologies for tonight's meeting: Councillor Eddie Dogramaci and Councillor Mike Creed. Could I have someone move Councillor Wheeler, seconded Councillor Reardon. All those in favour? Unanimous. Thank you.
RESOLVED on the motion of Councillor Reardon, seconded by Councillor Veigel that the minutes of the Ordinary Meeting held on 3 November 2026 be confirmed.
Thank you. Everybody, we'll get to those when we get to them. Could we have confirmation of the last minutes? Moved Councillor Reardon, seconded Councillor Veigel. All those in favour? Unanimous. Thank you.
RESOLVED on the motion of Councillor Sheather, seconded by Councillor Reardon.
That Council:
1. Defer consideration of the further treatment of the Kurrajong-Kurmond Soldier Settlement until further advice is received from Council's Heritage Advisory Committee regarding the recommendations of the Local Planning Panel.
2. Instruct staff to hold a public information session with property owners of properties with heritage potential in the Kurrajong-Kurmond area to discuss the process of local heritage listing, and the positive and negative implications of heritage listing.
In accordance with Section 375A of the Local Government Act 1993 a division is required to be called whenever a planning decision is put at a Council or Committee meeting. Accordingly, the Chairperson called for a division in respect of the motion, the results of which are as follows:
We will now move to our items for public address, and the first one of those is 10.1.1, which is the planning proposal for the Kurrajong Soldier Settlement heritage listings, and our first speaker is George Debool
George Daaboul(public speaker - Kurrajong resident)
Good evening, Mayor and Councillors and the member of the public. Thank you for the opportunity to address Council today. I am here to formally dispute the proposed heritage listing of my property at 1381 Kurmond Road, Kurmond. I'd like to start off by saying that this has caused immense stress and anxiety on me and my family since receiving the letter regarding the proposal. Not just for myself, but also other members in the community who have found themselves in the same position. I fully respect the historical significance of the soldier settlement and acknowledge the important contribution and sacrifices made by the servicemen and the families. I am not disputing the importance of preserving the history of the soldier settlement or its value in the community.
However, I strongly believe there must be a distinction between preserving the history of the soldier settlement as a whole and imposing individual heritage restrictions on a property that has been substantially reconstructed and modernised. I strongly believe the property does not retain sufficient original building fabric or historical integrity to justify heritage protection. When I purchased the property in 2008, it had active termite damage and asbestos throughout the interior. This required extensive reconstruction, not simply cosmetic renovations. The majority of the original structural timber, including wall studs, floor joists, bearers and roof timbers, were replaced. The entire interior was gutted and rebuilt using modern materials.
External elements were substantially replaced, including windows, cladding, roofing, plumbing, electrical, and a whole brand new shed. Also the actual wiring from the power pole to the actual house, three phase. For more details, please refer to the email sent to Mayor Lyons-Buckett and Andrew Carnes. My main concern is that Council appears to be placing significance on the federation style, a Federation appearance that does not mean the original Federation structure or heritage fabric exists. I am asking Council to properly consider the extent of these works and identify exactly what original heritage features remain and provide clear evidence of why this property and others qualify for heritage.
Another concern is the financial burden this will bring, such as renovations, repairs, maintenance, approvals, and especially building insurance. These costs are significantly higher than ordinary residential maintenance. I am asking the Council to consider not only the historical claims being made about this property, but also the real and ongoing financial consequences that heritage listing will impose on me. Respecting history is important, but so is fairness, common sense, and respecting my property ownership.
George Daaboul(public speaker - Kurrajong resident)
No, nobody. And I mean, even the letter, like, I got the letter one day and then it said there was a meeting on the third, and I got the letter after the actual fact, until I actually called the Council and made a few inquiries, and they said that you guys made an error. And yeah, and that's where we're at.
George Daaboul(public speaker - Kurrajong resident)
I mean, there's nothing left of the place, like, I've fully replaced, it's got vinyl cladding, your windows, the timbers, all the structure, even the brick piers, like the cement mortar, I'm a builder myself, was deteriorating. And at the time when I bought it, it was uninhabitable, and I've got an autistic child. And my daughter was only eight at the time, and I spent 10 months, seven days a week, with a couple of people trying to renovate it and fix it.
Thank you. My partner and I own a house in Mill Road, Kurrajong. We now learn it is proposed to have heritage listing applied. On the 4th of November, we received a notification letter dated the 29th of October for a 3rd of November meeting. A correction letter dated the 4th of November was received on the 12th of November. An update dated the 11th of November was received today, the 17th of November. At best, this is sloppy. I call it arrogant. These are important notifications. Has Council not heard about express post, telephone, email? You have all my details. I phoned Council on the 5th of November and asked for the person nominated in the letter. She or someone with knowledge of the matter will call back within two business days.
I'm still waiting for the call. Our house is a lovely cottage. We've owned it for 12 years. We love it. It's cosy, character-filled, and we like its historical significance. It's currently occupied by family members. It's in good condition, but not much is original. Only two external walls, two windows, the floor, and a disused fireplace. Prior to our ownership, significant modifications were undertaken. It was extended on three sides, two new bathrooms, new kitchen, new roof with a clerestory window, verandas, and outbuildings added. We plan to sell it in coming months, a significant part of our retirement savings. Business papers viewed today on Council's website have much more information than the 29th of October letter, including that this process is to obtain a gateway determination.
What does that mean to the average person? It wasn't explained. In Figure 2, why is my house and only one other tabbed blue and all the others are tabbed red? There was no legend, so I don't know. How does Council know it's in good condition? You haven't been inside it for at least 12 years, and all your photos are taken from realestate.com. I'm not here to object to or speak against the proposal. In principle, I support the preservation of our built heritage, but we haven't been given enough information to know whether it's a good or a bad thing for us. I, we, need and deserve more information. The original letter contains some FAQs. Here are some more really obvious ones. How long does this whole process take, given that a cloud will hang over it till it's resolved?
What are the implications for the value of my house? Has this rendered it effectively unsellable? I believe so. Anecdotally, I've told agents won't want to touch it. No sale, no commission. Who wants to buy a problem? What hoops do we or new owners have to go through to do any modifications? Development application is undertaken through a merits-based process considering all relevant provisions, and as such, a guidance note is not able to be prepared. Really? You haven't done this before ever? Who will make those determinations? Does Council have the relevant expertise in-house? Is there a dispute process? Does this apply equally across the board? Do I have to seek approval to renovate a bathroom, put in a window, but others can leave theirs to rot because they're not currently habitable, what I would call demolition by neglect?
Will I need to engage heritage consultants to support any development application? What about the statement in the advice letter that says it applies to the whole site? What if you want to build a shed, a pool? What are the heritage incentives referred to in the documents? The item 10.1 paper say Council officers will provide further guidance regarding the planning approval process and refer to community consultations post gateway. We need that further guidance now. Council needs to convene a meeting specifically for the 25 owners run by I appropriately informed and qualified Council staff so the owners can ask all the questions they have and hear all the answers. Once the gateway determination is made, this is off and running.
This is not a rubber stamp exercise. It's potentially game-changing for us and probably other owners. If my fears are unfounded, I need to know that now, not after some tortuous Department of Planning process. Maybe if the lady had called me back in two days as I was told she would, I wouldn't have to ask all these questions now.
Thank you. Thank you. Would you be happy to take any questions? Would you be happy to take any questions from councillors? Any questions, councillors? Councillor
McMahon. Thanks. Just a real quick one. You've said it, but I just want to confirm it again for the room. So in this report that we've had, and I've listened to everything you've said, not one representative from Council has ever come and had a look at your property.
No. You know, I assume you've taken all the photos from realestate.com, including the AI-generated one of the fire pit in the backyard with the flames coming out of it in the middle of a sunny afternoon. Okay. I just think it's sloppy.
No, I think that was important to note for the record, just that, and thank you for expressing the impact that this will have on your family. Appreciate it. Thank you.
Well, Mr Hunt's on the floor, Madam Mayor. He asked a question in relation to his property with the two blue dots on it. Can that be answered now, please?
Brenda Poster(public speaker - Kurrajong resident)
Thank you. This is my formal objection to proposed heritage listing of our property in 552 Bells Line of Road, Kurmond. Good afternoon, Mayor and Councillors, and the rest of the public behind. Thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak today. I'm here alongside with my partner because we are deeply concerned about the proposed heritage listing of our home. We want to make it very clear that we are not against preserving the history of our community. We understand that our property may have significance and we respect that. But behind this proposal is a real family who will be responsible for the property and its maintenance and its cost. Our existing house is already in a very poor and deteriorating condition.
It has reached a point where maintaining and repairing it is not simply a matter of doing a little work here and there. It requires significant attention, work and money. My partner and I have spent a long time trying to get ourselves financially back on our feet so that in the near future we can finally make some decisions about the future of our property and our home. This proposal has therefore come at a very difficult time for us. Our concern is that if the property is heritage listed, the financial and practical responsibility placed upon us could become even greater. We are worried about the cost and maintaining, repairing or restoring a deteriorating house while also having restrictions on what we can and cannot do with it.
We are ordinary people. We don't have unlimited financial resources to restore an old house to heritage standards. We are asking Council to please look beyond the history of the building and also consider the people who own it today. We have lived— sorry— with this property, its condition, and we know what is realistically involved in trying to maintain it. We are not asking Council to disregard heritage. We are asking Council to consider whether it is fair and reasonable to place these obligations on us without properly considering the condition of the house and the financial impact it could have on our family. We simply want the opportunity to move forward with our lives and make responsible decisions about our property and our future.
I respectfully ask Council to listen to our concerns, consider our circumstances, and carefully reconsider the proposed heritage listing. Thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak today.
Thank you very much. Would you be happy to answer any questions? Yes, if I can, I will. Any questions, Councillors? No questions. Thank you for that. Thank you. That completes our speakers, Councillors. Just before we move on to debate the item, I would just ask the Director of City Planning to give a brief outline around the process that may clear up some of the reasons why there wasn't more information given upfront about this, and potentially if you wish to say anything about the restrictions or anything like that, that may help inform the debate. Thank you .
Thank you through you, Madam Mayor. Whilst a lot of background work and research and publications have been prepared to date, this report before Council is actually the start of the process. The report before Council asks Council whether or not they would like to commence a process to consider heritage listing of these buildings. It doesn't ask Council to make a decision tonight that yes, they should be listed. It asks Council whether or not they'd like to commence the process. If Council does wish to commence the process, then we start. The reason we have not been able to undertake any form of consultation with the property owners is due to the State Government's LEP plan-making guidelines and restrictions they have on councils around planning proposals, and that applies not just to this planning proposal, but all other planning proposals that Council is dealing with at the moment.
If Council does decide that they would like to commence this process, then the next step is getting the Council resolution, sending the package of documentation off to the Department of Planning, who then consider the documentation and determine whether or not they issue a gateway determination. If that all happens and if we get a gateway determination, the next step in the process is to commence the public consultation process, and that process will include further letters to all the property owners that will enable Council officers to have discussions with property owners, and that could be one-on-one, that could be in large group, small group, that could take a whole range of different forms.
And following that consultation process, Council officers will then take on board all the feedback we've received through all the different mechanisms part of consultation, and we have to prepare a report back to Council outlining all the issues that were raised during the consultation process and provide commentary on those issues, and that report comes to a Council meeting for Council's consideration. And if we get to that point, everyone who's made a submission is then advised of that Council meeting and advised of the opportunity to come and address Council. In terms of how long this process takes, Council has certain steps that we do and the Department of Planning has certain steps that they undertake.
The typical planning proposal process can take 12 to 18 months. Council would not make a decision on whether to actually go forward with listing of any items. That decision wouldn't be made by Council until Council has considered all the outcomes of the formal statutory consultation process. The other thing that I'll just mention in passing, in terms of the red and blue dots on the map, they are not significant. The blue dots are not significant. They will just be the dots that were clicked on when the map was generated. So all the dots, regardless of the colour, are just identifying the location of the potential heritage items.
Thank you, Monica . Would— can I just clarify before we start off? So within this process, would it be— this is a starting list. There would be some properties that could be dropped off, or depending on the consultation, just to clarify that this isn't a set list
Through you, Madam Mayor, yes, that is correct. So through the consultation process, Council would receive submissions, and in responding to those submissions, it may be that the recommendation to Council does indeed drop some properties off that list. And then Council, in turn, can also make a decision that may differ from the recommendation.
Through you, Madam Mayor, yes, that is correct. So there was an administrative error, and the wrong date of the Council meeting went out in the first letter, being the 3rd of November, which was then corrected to identify tonight's meeting being the 17th of November. So that was an unfortunate typo.
I'll pass to the Director of City Planning. Through you, Madam Mayor, any planning proposal we receive at the moment, as of sort of end of November, or November, no consultation is happening prior to that. If we receive a planning proposal from an applicant, the applicant may consult with the landowners, but they are not obliged to. It's different to a DA where you need owners' consent to submit.
Through you, Madam Mayor, yes. As I've explained, we have notified the property owners in this instance as a courtesy of tonight being the commencement of the process, but— Due to the state government's LEP plan making requirements, we are not able to undertake any consultation prior to Council considering the matter tonight.
Thank you. Yeah, thanks, Madam Mayor. Well, I'll speak in favour of the motion. It's fairly obvious from the people who spoke to us tonight, and if we're supporting legislation in this regard, we're acting extremely poor. We've heard that someone do work on their property, others want to sell perhaps their property. I don't care what they've got to do, really. It's their goddamn property. And to put in place, and, like, I've been through a couple of these things in my time on Council, and it's taken a long time, and that's one of the reasons we've got a heritage committee that come up with great proposals. But you need to take both the community and property owners with you on where you're looking at projects that, certainly of this magnitude.
We've never had anything come to us as big as this before. It's massive. And to think the very people that we're trying to work with to preserve some of our history and the likes, they've already seen that because they bought the properties. They're well aware of where they live and the environment they live in. And to, without consultation, doesn't allow them, as one of the speakers indicated, to know whether they're on the loose end of a tightrope. Or hang it off the other end of it. So, Madam Mayor, I don't know the process. We haven't had the opportunity to have a briefing about it, the likes, and that's been up and down again through state government decisions, which is probably the issue that we're in today.
But there's got to be some way that if we propose to look after our community in the best interest of our community, there's got to be a better way than this. There's only a small section of the amount of homes that's involved there, but from the passion that's involved with it, I'd suggest, as if I am one of those places, that at the end of the day maybe they're not against it, but they haven't been given the opportunity to be involved. And if someone come to me in relation to any property I own, the gum legislation is a good one to come up, actually, that it's grossly unfair for people who are aware of their assets and feel as though it's been intruded without their consultation. So I'm not saying that I oppose where this is headed.
I think down the track. But whether, and we're only looking at a percentage of the amount of some of the homes that's involved anyway. We're not looking at the total amount. But I would suggest we go a long way further, and with better results, by having those discussions as one of the indicated. I don't know how we can do that legally or the like.
Director of City Planning. Thank you through you, Madam Mayor. If Council wishes to receive a report on the views of the community on this proposal, then the way the state government framework is set up, Council would need to resolve to proceed with the planning proposal tonight. That's the only way staff can undertake consultation with the property owners, and the only way we can provide a report back to Council detailing the views of the property owners. Council does have the option to resolve not to proceed with this motion at all tonight. That is an option available for Council if you do not wish to proceed. If Council wishes to get the views of the community in a report to Council, then we would need Council to resolve to move forward.
Yeah, thanks for that, Madam Mayor. Madam Mayor, I'll just reiterate, I'm not opposed to this. I'm opposed to the process. And the reason that I didn't include or direct the staff in where to go, I think that the staff, after the discussions they've heard tonight, would be well aware of what options there might be or the like. So I'm not suggesting in the motion that we don't move forward, but if the staff feel it's important to say — That's gone into it, but it is that I suggest we find a way to do it.
Thank you, Councillor Sheather, but your motion does not give us a way to do it. The Director of City Planning has just said we cannot undertake consultation unless we've resolved. So really, the choice appears to be to not support it and leave it, or to give some detail about maybe approaching the State Government. I don't know, but the staff have said that legally they cannot undertake that consultation unless we have a resolution before us to do that. Can
Sorry to chime in at this stage. I would suggest that we amend Councillor Sheather's motion to receive and note this item, and to not go ahead with this planning proposal. I'm saying that with the understanding that it can be revisited further down the track if required. Not going ahead, I'll have to get a seconder, shall I, before I speak to it? Yes, a seconder. Seconder, Councillor Veigel. Thank you. But I guess I'll ask that question. If we don't go ahead with the planning proposal at this time, what is the process for revisiting it after we have done more than seemingly a desktop analysis? Director of
Planning. Through you, Madam Mayor, to say we have only done a desktop analysis is perhaps not reflective of the body of research that's gone into this. There's been the formal publication, there's been the work of Dr Terry Cass. Council's Heritage Working Group has considered this matter, and also Council's Heritage Committee has considered the matter. Those groups are advisory groups that provide advice to Council, and Council ultimately makes the decision. If Council resolved not to proceed with this matter tonight, then the status quo remains in place. The Heritage Committee would be advised of Council's resolution, and the matter would just remain with the Heritage Committee and other interested people within the community until such time that there was an impetus for it to be revisited by Council.
Thank you. That was good to know, because I think that if we don't go ahead with the planning proposal, it seems to me that we will be able to have community consultation via some other project mechanism where people actually do get to give us more information about their properties. And also, it is still a little mystifying to me why these particular properties were chosen over others. I think that's an understandable question. I'm sorry if the reasoning behind it is contained in this. I was just a bit, I was a bit overwhelmed with this item, I've got to say. I think that, as Councillor Sheather said, we need to have a way forward, and the way forward, I think, is to not do this under the guise of the state government's new planning structures, and not a planning proposal.
I don't think it's ready to be a planning proposal. There's obviously some more work that we have to do, and we have to bring our community along with us. And I understand that staff, and I'm not blaming the staff for not consulting, because that was the directive from the state government, and they're our minders, and that's what we do. But that doesn't negate the fact that, or it doesn't stop us choosing to have a different process. And I appreciate that the Heritage Committee and the other people that have researched this are much more knowledgeable about the heritage significance of these properties. But at the moment, it's just not, something seems not right with it, and I think we just have to draw a line in the sand and cut it off now and regroup, talk to people about what they might be able to contribute.
At the moment, this is hitting people. In all of the wrong sorts of ways. And I'm quite upset that that's happened because it's obvious we have three members of our community that have spoken to us tonight, and it's obvious that they're upset. And I don't know what other people on that list are feeling, but that's not acceptable. I'll leave it at that because I think we have to, I think we just have to make that decision, and then we can regroup without that barrier or being contained by the processes that we need to follow in the planning proposal procedures. So that's my solution to this problem. Happy to augment my motion
Or my amendment. Thank you. Thank you, Councillor Kotlash. I'll just see if there's a comment from the Director of Planning on the content of the amendment
Thank you, through you, Madam Mayor. If Council resolves not to proceed with this planning proposal tonight, that is completely fine. That's a matter for Council to decide. If that is the decision of Council, then the process just stops. So we don't really have the ability to undertake consultation with people. There may be informal discussions between members of the Heritage Committee and members of the community, but none of that would be decision making, and we wouldn't be able to present any of that back to Council in a formal report. The only way we can provide a formal report to Council on the views of the property owners is if Council wishes to go down this process. But it is completely valid to resolve not to proceed.
Thank you. Can I ask another question, if I may, Madam Mayor? I understand that there can't be community consultation in this process, and I get that. Is there— there must have been some sort of consultation for us to get to 25 properties out of 47. I mean, we must have had some sort of— there must have been some sort of process to— and forgive me for saying it was a desktop assessment, because it just sounded like it was, because it just sounded like nobody had actually had any inspections done, and I find that very problematic. But I think— is there a question, Councillor? Yes, there is. How— sorry, how can't we just have another project or another process where we talk to people, not calling it formal consultation, but just talk to people about how we— what we're up to with this sort of heritage assets ? Can we just not— can we just sort of not have this formal structure
Director of Planning. Through you, Madam Mayor, that is very challenging because it does deal with private property. So if we were dealing with public property, public assets, that would be slightly different. But because it deals with private property, we really need to go through this formalised process, and it is a state government process , not a process that council officers have put in place. All councils have to follow this process if they wish to consider— Additional heritage item listings, or not. Thank you, Councillor Reardon. Yes,
Thank you, Madam Mayor. As a member of the Heritage Committee, I understand that with our report that many of these properties have been modified, therefore would not be suitable to be heritage listed. And I think these people have been caused a lot of concern, and I move that we don't go ahead with this.
Okay. Thank you, Councillor Reardon. Councillor Wheeler. Thanks, Madam Mayor. I'll foreshadow an amendment and then speak against the amendment that's in front of us. I think it's possible for us to perhaps defer consideration of this rather than kick it to the curb completely, and at the very least hold a public information session with property owners, potentially heritage-listed property owners in the Kurrajong, Kurmond area, to discuss the implications of heritage listing and the process of heritage listing. It doesn't have to refer to this planning proposal particularly; it can just refer to the mechanism of planning proposals and outline the pros and cons of having a heritage-listed property. I think that gets around the state government prohibition whilst not throwing this whole process out completely. Thank you , Councillor Djuric.
It's currently a foreshadowed amendment, depending on whether the other amendment goes through or not. I'll just let Councillor Wheeler speak against the amendment, as she just indicated she will. Yeah,
So I'll speak against this amendment. Because of the—we are in an awkward position, I think, because of the fairly recent changes to planning proposals from the state government. So we have passed a large planning proposal of this type that involved multiple property owners with the slab barn listing scheme. None of those owners were consulted and asked whether they wanted their properties listed. I am one of those property owners. Yes, we had people come and inspect our property and take lots of photos and all of that, but that's because we had a slab of funding from the state government to run the slab barn study early on in the piece, and council then allocated a slab of funding for consultants to go out and inspect those barns.
Some of those owners were very unhappy. That's what happens with heritage listings. If we only listed— councils can take two approaches to heritage listings. They can list what's worthy and needs protection, or they can work out what's worthy and needs protection and then go and ask owners and say, Do you want your property listed and protected? Nine times out of ten, the owners that don't want their property listed and protected are people, once they understand what's happening, are people who want to so modify that property that, usually by demolition, that they don't want the listing holding them up. Once people are informed about what a listing means and they understand that the process doesn't mean that you can't change the colour of your kitchen, that you can't ever put an extension on, that you will never be able to build a garage, that it isn't this enormous impost.
Most people are very happy to have that additional layer of acknowledgement , I suppose, of the value of their property. Yes, sometimes it costs a bit more. In Australia, we don't have a particularly good record for selling heritage as part of real estate. The UK is very, very different. I know when we bought our house, you know, nearly 30 years ago, we were relieved that it wasn't listed. It wasn't listed because of a mistake. Part of it is now listed, and I am anxiously waiting for the rest of it to be listed because I realise that that house is important. These properties are really important. They're a really important piece of the Hawkesbury's fabric. Protecting them doesn't mean that the owners will never be able to do anything to them.
It doesn't mean that they will be hugely more expensive to insure, or that the owners will be really restricted in what they can do. It does mean that they can't demolish them. Yes, that is part of a heritage listing, and they have a right to know that before the listing is final. But just because the owner of a heritage item says to us, I want to demolish my property, shouldn't always be a reason for Council to balk at protecting the important historical fabric of the LGA. That's the hard decision that we have to make when we sit around this table. Not all of the properties that were part of the original soldier settlement are intact enough to warrant listing. That's why they're not on the list.
Those that are still indicative of the soldier settlement fabric, the types of building, the scale of building, the arrangement of building, and the use of the sites that they... that are worthy of listing, and their protection is important. This is hard. That's why we get paid the big bucks, because this is hard.
Thank you, Madam Mayor. Firstly, a question to staff, and it relates to the timeline on this. Could I just get staff to clarify on what date individual landowners were informed , per recommendation two of the HLPP advice?
Director of Planning. Thank you through you, Mr Mayor—Madam Mayor, sorry. Yes, the Hawkesbury Local Planning Panel recommended that landowners be notified a month prior to the Council meeting. That is advice from the Local Planning Panel for consideration. Because of the State Government's recent changes to the LEP plan-making requirements, we had to abide by those requirements, and we struck a compromise by notifying the property owners two weeks prior to the Council meeting to strike a balance between the LEP plan-making requirements that don't really allow us to consult with people, but to notify as a courtesy of this meeting, which is actually the commencement of the process.
Thank you. All right then. I find that frustrating and disturbing. The idea that we are constrained by some higher statute merely even to just inform, you know, not to engage in some elaborate or formal consultation process, but merely to say— We want to let people know that this is coming to the chamber. Clearly that was the intent of the HLPP. And if they met on the 15th of October, and let's imagine that it was a, you know, a week before that could be turned around, then clearly those residents weren't given their four weeks' notice. And I hear in the debate around the table what sounds like a tragic case of crossed wires. I've sat on our heritage committee for some years, and my heart inclines towards giving recognition and protection to our heritage, particularly if it's at risk.
And yet I've had a series of distressed emails and conversations, including with Mr Bentvelzen, whose late wife actually wrote part of the documentation that's formed part of the consideration for this issue. And he was telling me that she would be aghast. She would not have intended that the historical research that she undertook that would be used in this way. But then in talking that matter through with him and others, I get the sense that it's not as though people are against the recognition of that heritage. They're concerned and uncertain about the way in which the provisions of the LEP would be interpreted. They are concerned and uncertain about what restrictions might apply to the way that they can modify their properties.
There was certainly a vein of being concerned and uncertain about if there was an implication for the sale or value of their property. And I recognise the comments that staff have made, but it feels like we've taken a wrong turn wherever we could have taken a wrong turn. I would love to support this. In fact, I do support this. If Councillor Wheeler is able to bring her foreshadowed motion to either defer this or to bring the original recommendation, I will vote for it, because I recognise that this is the beginning of a process, and it opens the door off the back of a really substantial body of work that's been done in good faith to try and begin that conversation with residents, and that what we've failed to do is to bring those residents and landowners with us to help them understand that we're not seeking to ride roughshod over them, and that there are likely to be acceptable answers to those questions relating to modification of their property, the value of their property, their voice in this process.
I think many people who own heritage understand that they are stewards as well as investors and want to partner with organisations like Council, but Council has to deal in good faith. So by failing to provide the kind of notice that was recommended in writing by the HLPP, immediately we've wrong-footed. We've wrong-footed ourselves with those property owners. There is now a lack of trust and a lack of faith, and I don't agree with Councillor Sheather or Councillor Kotlash that this process should stop dead. I think that would be unwise and it would ignore the body of good work that's gone into this process to date. I think what we need to do is take pause. Use what mechanisms we can to try and help these residents understand what's being proposed, allay their concerns, and then return to this in a timely fashion.
A comment from the Director of Planning. Thank you, through you, Madam Mayor. Yes, we could undertake a generic public information session about heritage, explaining what a heritage listing is, what its implications are. We could also explain the planning proposal process, but that would be a generic public information session and it wouldn't result in a report back to Council on the views of the community.
Director of City Planning. Through you, Madam Mayor, probably the key mechanism to revitalise it at a later date would be advice from Council's Heritage Committee, which would then come through a staff report and a report would be back to Council.
A second question, if I may, Madam Mayor. The reason I ask is that— By moving the amendment that I have, I was seeking to put a stop to the constraints that we have with consulting with people. And I thought if we agree to stop this process now, as long as we can pick it up. I actually don't particularly want to see this stop either. I think it's a process that we need to go through. But if we stop it now, and presumably we are free of those constraints, then we can, at a later date, when we have more information— is that, I'm sorry, I am going to ask a question—is that a fair assessment of how we might get around this problem of
Not — Director of Planning, could you please clarify? Because we have this amendment and Councillor Kotlash's question, and we had Councillor Wheeler's foreshadowed motion. I think they actually, they sort of go hand in hand, although this one is actually saying not to proceed with the planning proposal, whereas Councillor Wheeler foreshadowed moving to a different consultation. What would be the status of the planning proposal in that instance? It would just simply wait as it does, or
What would happen in that case? Through you, Madam Mayor, there's a couple of things here. So one option is Council resolves not to proceed with the planning proposal, and as part of that, Council could resolve to have staff conduct a generic public information session around heritage in the Kurrajong area and leave it at that. Another, and then it could play out its course. The Heritage Committee no doubt would consider this matter, and potentially at some point next year, the matter could return to Council for consideration. Council could— yeah, I think if Council has an appetite for staff to conduct a generic public information session, probably the best path forward is to not proceed with the planning proposal and have staff do that, with the opportunity to reconsider the planning proposal at a later date, next year sometime, no specified time.
Alternatively, Council potentially can resolve to proceed with the planning proposal, and then we are bound by the consultation requirements of the State Government's planning process.
Thank you, Madam Mayor. Look, I'll support this. I believe the people sitting behind me here need to walk out of this chamber with some confidence that we are making a decision, a decision for our history, but also a decision that they are involved in and it's part of their life. I know a reasonable amount about historical buildings and all the issues we've had with them, and I think the Councillor Wheeler's idea of giving them a generic overview of what's happening would probably be the best way for them to start, and then they can pick up on their own information. We all know how to use AI these days. I've even used it in the last week. So this is something I think we can prepare them for and take away the big brother attitude towards them and just say, okay, let's prepare, let's move forward, and let's do it as a team and work together so that we get the best results for the people and for our historical value of these homes.
Thank you, Councillor Ryan. You have just spoken, though, to Councillor Wheeler's foreshadowed amendment. I'm just wondering if Councillor Kotlash wants to amend in any way hers to reflect what the Director of Planning had just said about the generic session as well, which we need a resolution for or we cannot. Can I
Just start with a question? I'm sorry, it's a question for clarification. Is it possible for there to be a generic workshop where people are invited to understand the planning process in both scenarios, in the foreshadowed amendment and the amendment that's on the screen? Is that what you said before,
So Council could resolve not to proceed and require staff to run a generic information session. Council could resolve to defer the matter and staff run a generic information session, noting that, again not in the recommendation or resolution, but noting that if we do run a generic information session, there won't be a formal report back to Council as a result of that. So, yeah, under those two scenarios, not proceed or defer, a generic information session could be held.
Just to clarify that. Thank you. Deferment would mean we get a report back to Council, but not proceeding would mean we don't. That's the difference. Yeah. Do you want
It as is? No, no, that's, I think I'm clearer on what could happen. So I'd suggest that we still not proceed with the planning proposal, that we— Have a generic workshop to help our residents who are impacted by this understand this incredibly complex process and the constraints that we are under. I'd also add a point that we ask the Heritage Committee to prepare a project or a proposal where they can go out and consult with owners
The Heritage Committee should be able to give Council advice on all of these sorts of issues that we face. That's their role, to give us advice. And I would like to have their advice on how we can make this fairer and presumably better for heritage protection.
Councillor. We had a motion from Councillor Kotlash. She spoke to it. We all spoke to it. I foreshadowed an amendment. Yes. And now we're making a motion on the fly— You're right. —requiring the Heritage Committee to give advice to Council that it's already given to Council, that Council hasn't read. Thank you, Councillor Wheeler. I'll uphold that
We'll move on. If there's no further discussion on the amendment, we'll put the amendment before us. We have a foreshadowed amendment on the table as well. So I'll put Councillor Kotlash's amendment is that Council receive and note this item and not proceed with planning proposal LEP 00526, Kurrajong Soldiers Settlement heritage listings. All those in favour? Not yet. Not yet. After the amendment. All those in favour of that amendment? Councillor Kotlash, Councillor McMahon, Councillor Reardon and Councillor Veigel. Against? Councillor Wheeler, Councillor Ryan, Councillor Zamprogno, Councillor Sheather, Councillor Djuric and Councillor Lyons-Buckett. The amendment is lost. Your amendment, Councillor Wheeler, and seconded by Councillor Durick.
For the benefit of the public, if you can't see that, the proposed amendment is to defer consideration of the further treatment of the Kurrajong Kurmond Soldiers Settlement until further advice is received from Council's Heritage Advisory Committee, is that it, regarding the recommendations of the Local Planning Panel. Number two, instruct staff to hold— Is that the correct one? Is that the correct— Instruct staff to hold a public information session with property owners of properties with heritage potential in the Kurrajong Kurmond area to discuss the process of local heritage listing and the positive and negative implications of heritage listing. Councillor Wheeler, would you like to speak to your amendment?
What I'm attempting to do here is at least keep this alive in the system whilst getting around the state government prohibition on speaking to affected property owners about a planning proposal. Because I agree, it has got us off on the wrong foot, basically. It's left Council in a really invidious position of looking like it's trying to hoodwink the owners of these properties. And I think this is, you know, when we go to LG NSW next week and this matter comes up for discussion on the floor, I think we've got a really nice example of how this really damages the relationship between Council and Council staff and members of the community who are affected by decisions like this. The Planning Panel has made, I think, some strange recommendations or problematic recommendations to Council, and I would really like the Heritage Advisory Committee's guidance on some of those recommendations, particularly the ones about Council assessing the structural integrity of each property.
I think that's incredibly invasive, for a start. It's also very costly, and I think unprecedented. Certainly none of the slab barns were assessed for their structural integrity. We wouldn't have listed 90 percent of them . So I would really like that information to come back to the Heritage Committee and that to be considered. Point two is an attempt to make such a broad recommendation that it stays outside the state government's... Prohibition on public information to potential planning proposals, so, and which is, I hope, what it achieves Look, the soldier settlements are a really important part of both the fabric of the Hawkesbury and the story of Australia. They're an attempt to help returned servicemen rebuild their lives while also ensure the spread and cultivation of land across Australia.
They occurred in almost every state, and the Kurrajong-Curmond soldier settlement probably represents the attempt that was on some of the land most likely to prosper, but also was closest to market. Some of these properties, particularly in Victoria and South Australia, were in the most appalling circumstances. Very few people got something as beautiful as Kurrajong and Kurmond. They very often failed. These men who were broken by war with their young families were settled far from help, far from support, often on very marginal land. Most had no farming skills; they weren't farmers. And then the Depression hit them as well. The vast majority of them failed. The fact that these soldier settlements still survive on what is now the edge of Sydney in the Kurrajong-Curmond area is quite remarkable, and they really do deserve protection.
It's actually really gratifying to hear the owners of them come and speak to us about the high regard in which they hold them. But it's important that they continue to hold them in high regard and see heritage listing as an opportunity rather than just an encumbrance. And I think that's our role, to show them that there are advantages to heritage listing, including having Council's excellent heritage advisor come and talk to them about what might need to be done and how it can be done without breaking the bank with some of these properties, but also to open up access to heritage assistance grants and things. And we've seen that with the success of the Slab Barn listing. It's possible that one of the recommendations from the Heritage Advisory Committee or Council is that we have a round of heritage assistance funding that is particular to these listings, as we did with the Slab Barn study, which would increase the amount available to each property owner.
But we can't get there until everybody understands what this means for them. So hopefully this keeps this alive, but also gives people a bit more information about what is likely to happen in the next few months. Heritage listing is quite a slow process. You know, the Slab Barn study listings still aren't completed. So thank you.
Thank you, Madam Mayor. I supported Councillor Kotlash's amendment, but I'm also happy to support the one on the board right now. And I hope that our public speakers who spoke to us tonight can take some satisfaction away when they leave this evening that As an elected body, we really laboured over what to do in this particular circumstance. And right now, it's not a green light, but it's not a red light. And I think that's what I'm taking from the current motion on the board. And it's finding a way to circumnavigate those legislative restrictions that the staff have articulated so well that are not council's restrictions; they're state government restrictions. So I think that that's a way to try and get around that.
And you can't go wrong with giving more education and information. And I think, I hope this is sort of like a broader lesson for everybody here, that when we have a planning proposal or something like this that we want to go forward, knowing that we can't break the law, there are ways that we can bring our community with us on the journey rather than sort of a harsh letter that says this is happening, without that supporting information that's needed to guide them through such a process. So I think the scary thing about it too is we really are in challenging economic times, and without all of the information of what this might mean prior, I understand that the speakers and the other families who may be impacted by this, it's a scary thought of what that would mean financially for their families, what that would mean about their ability or their inability to do things to their home that they want to do.
So that's why I took on board those concerns tonight of the speakers. I want to thank you for coming. It's really difficult to get up and speak in front of councillors or politicians. I understand that, so thank you for doing that. I think it really impacted all of us to try and come to this resolution tonight where we're pushing it a bit further down the path until we make a final decision. But hopefully along that way, you'll have more information and you can engage further with our staff and with us about— What that means to you and your family. So I do welcome what is on the board now. I'm happy to support it, and I do encourage anyone who may be impacted to come and speak to us, like I said.
The more information we can get as decision makers, the better. Thank you.
Thank you, Madam Mayor. I'm going to speak against the amendment. I guess I am a bit confused with what the advantage of deferring further consideration would be in this particular situation. We've had it laboured to us that the state government will not allow any consultation prior to a gateway determination. So if the people that are, the councillors that have spoken about keeping this process alive surely should not want to defer it and would want that gateway determination so that we could get to a state that we could actually start consulting with the people that own these properties. So I'm a bit perplexed with what advantage no further treatment in this amendment will do. That's why I said if we just stop the process, we can get off this constraint train and start to reshape this whole process.
So I think that the public information session is essential, and I'm not sure why we don't do that as a rule, because heritage and these sorts of planning processes are very complex and quite confusing. So I'm not sure why we don't do that as a rule, if we can do it in a generic way. So I'm not happy to support this. I just don't think this is a— I don't know what the Heritage Committee is going to be able to do, what further treatment that might be. Thanks. Thank you, Councillor Sheather
Just through you, Madam Mayor, to Councillor Wheeler, how long was the heritage barn process from when it first started through your committee to when it got to Council? Councillor Wheeler. The process and how many—how long?
So there's two stages. There was the process to get it to Council, which was— the initial report was done in 2011, and Council refused to adopt it. Then Council paid for the consultants to update that report, which took five or six months, I think. That was then reported to the Heritage Committee, which was then reported to Council. Council—I don't know, I was out of the room for a lot of these discussions because I have a pecuniary interest. And then that process was sent to the State Department for consideration to Gateway. Of course, back then we could inform residents before it went to Gateway. It went to Gateway, it came back from Gateway. I think the Planning Panel had their two penneth worth, and then this Council, I think it came to this Council twice in that process, and it's now gone.
Back to the state government. It's been on public exhibition. It went back to the state government, and I think we're now waiting for it to be finally signed off in the LEP. So at least 18 months from the time that the consultant's report was received by Council. In this instance, in lieu of the consultant's report, what we have is the heritage sheets that have been provided by the Heritage Listing Committee and the work of Dr Terry Cass to ensure that those heritage listing sheets are correct, based on some of the information that's been given to us tonight, including the book that's been previously referred to. Much of the work on this was done by a local community member who's an expert on the soldier settlements.
Councillor Wheeler. I think we've had a lot of discussion on this. I'd just like to point out to the members of the public who came along and spoke tonight, first of all, to thank them for sharing their concerns. And I think perhaps this has given them a bit of an insight into the systemic challenges that we face when we are bound by various rules that prevent us from doing what we may think is best. In this situation, I think it's been confused by the Planning Panel advice, which I don't think was overly helpful in the process. But I think that the amendment has come up with a way forward, albeit a deferral for which we are often criticised. And I think that it gives a way how we can have the staff continue to engage with people, owners of properties with heritage.
Now, the owners of properties with heritage in the Kurrajong-Kurmond area are not only soldier settlement. We have other heritage listed, or properties which may be heritage listed in that area. So educating people around how we can balance both protecting heritage. And enabling people to work within their own properties to realise the value of that heritage while not being constrained from, you know, having the sort of property they want to live on is a really important exercise, and I welcome that because I really acknowledge and value how much work people put into them, regardless of what direction they have taken that renovation or, you know, application of how they want to preserve something which is a very special cottage that they happen to have bought.
So it's not about restricting people. It's not about depriving people of the ability to realise the value or the worth of their property. It's about recognising within our community some of the unique and valuable assets that we have, and there are advantages as well to heritage listings, sometimes around reuse of a second sort of building that may be on that property, et cetera, et cetera. But that would be for a better understanding. And I fully acknowledge that that understanding has not been within the community that feels they're being impacted by this, and I welcome the opportunity that they will have to be able
Understand this while the planning proposal still remains something that we may proceed with. And of course, having said that, as clarified before, it doesn't mean every property would be recommended for listing. It just means that those properties that are here were identified in studies as being of that particular class of building from the soldier settlement, I don't know what you'd call it, scheme, I guess, which was done after the war. So I'm going to support Councillor Wheeler's amendment. And are there any further discussions, councillors?
A question A question of you, Madam Mayor. The State Government gives $5,000 for great support to such projects. We increased ours to $100,000 a couple of years ago.
Should add. No, I just wanted to clarify, Madam Mayor, in relation to Council support, both for a process and to support people who would take an undertaking that Council supports financially that direction.
All right, we'll vote on Councillor Wheeler's amendment. All those in favour? Councillor McMahon, Councillor Wheeler, Councillor Ryan, Councillor Zamprogno, Councillor Sheather, Councillor Veigel, Councillor Jury and Councillor Lyons-Buckett. Against? Councillor Kotlash and Councillor Reardon. The amendment is carried and will become the motion. Councillor Sheather, right of reply. Not necessary. Not necessary. We'll now vote on the motion. All those in favour? Councillor McMahon, Councillor Wheeler, Councillor Ryan, Councillor Zamprogno, Councillor Sheather, Councillor Veigel, Councillor Jury, Councillor Lyons-Buckett. Against? Councillor Kotlash and Councillor Reardon. The motion is carried.
Thank you, Councillors. We now, I believe, will have the auditor. Is the auditor here? We'll now— could I have someone move a procedural— oh no, is that next on the list? Oh, it's next on the list. That's okay. Thank you. Thank you for speaking on the issue. Thank you.
Our next item is item 10.4.1, which is the presentation from the New South Wales Audit Office, Kenneth Leung and Larissa Chan, and they are online and they have a presentation as well. Thank you. And councillors can ask questions after the presentation. Thank you
So good evening, everyone. So before I start, I'd just like to thank Council for inviting Kenneth and I along this evening. It's a great opportunity to meet with you and provide an overview of the audit outcomes and answer any questions that you might have. So I'm pleased to say that we've now completed the audit of the financial statements and we've issued an unqualified audit opinion. So in other words, the financial statements present fairly and don't contain material misstatements. I'll first hand over to Kenneth, so he will take you through the conduct report, so that details Council's performance. I'll then provide a brief update on some of the audit office's broader work, so that includes our annual work program, the upcoming local government sector report to Parliament, and the performance audits that are planned in the local government space. So over to you, Kenneth.
Thanks, Larissa, and thank you, Madam Mayor, again for the opportunity to present to Council on the financial results for the 2026 financial year. So I'll start off with this graph, which shows the operating results for Council over the last three years, and the operating result shows how much Council's revenue exceeded its expenses. And the positive is that Council reported a $57.1 million operating surplus from its continuing operations, which was, whilst it was below the 2025 level, this was largely due to the fact that there were a number of large developer contributions that were received by Council in the last financial year, and this was broadly in line with the overall long-term financial results.
Other expenses also increased slightly, largely due to a remeasurement of Council's tip remediation provision . So over to the next slide, please. So this graph shows Council's revenue composition. Total revenue was about $210 million, which again was down mostly due to the decrease in the grants and contributions because of the one-off developer contribution that was received last year. But all in all, Council's rates and annual charges did increase by about $16.2 million to just under $90 million, and the continuing operations also included in this financial year the impact of a $12 million sewerage annual charge. Next slide, please. Over to cash flows. So Council's net cash flow was a positive $7.3 million compared to a negative $2.6 million outflow in the last financial year, and this was reflected largely due to an increase in the cash from operating activities, which Reached a positive 111 million.
There was also offset by about a $91 million cash outflow from investment activities, mostly due to purchases of property, plant and equipment, as well as repayments in financing activities . Next slide, please. Turning to cash, so cash and investments. This graph shows the breakup between what's your external restricted cash, what are some of the internal allocations, as well as the unrestricted cash. So total external restrictions was around 103 million, which made up the lion's share of Council's total cash and investments. There was also an internal allocation of 35 million, approximately, and Council's unrestricted funds has returned to a positive position of just around 411,000 in the current year, which was, I guess, a positive and a reflection of the increase in cash.
This graph just shows the breakdown of Council's externally restricted cash, and these are cash amounts that are subject to legal or contractual obligations, which limit how Council can use these. And again, the lion's share comes from developer contributions that were received by Council. Other significant buckets include your sewer fund and domestic waste management. Next slide, please. So this graph shows Council's unrestricted current ratio, which measures Council's ability to pay its short-term obligations. As and when they fall due, and Council's ratio was 2.8 times compared with 2.9 times. So there is a decreasing trend here , but nevertheless, Council still has, I guess, sufficient assets to meet its obligations over the next 12 months.
Over to the next slide. Council liquidity measures the available cash and investments to meet short-term expenditure, and again, these exclude any externally restricted balances. Based on this, Council does have adequate funds to fund roughly 3.6 months of expenditure from its available cash reserves, which was broadly consistent with the prior year and a general upward trend over the last three years. Next
This slide just, I guess, highlights Council's loans. So Council does have a $42.8 million loan with financial institutions compared with $54.8 million last year, which shows Council has paid down some of its debt. And these loans were largely used to fund the reconstruction of the Sewell Rising Main, the Infrastructure Borrowing Program, as well as the Vineyard Precinct Low Cost Loan Initiative.
Slide. Finally, in terms of infrastructure, property, plant and equipment, Council spent approximately $116 million on IPP&E during the 2026 financial year. About 53 million of this was in asset renewals and new assets of 63 million, and the lion's share of this went to capital works in progress, with, I guess, other critical areas being roads, bridges and footpaths, as well as land and buildings. I'll now pass over to Larissa just to give Council a highlight on the audit work program. So over to you, Larissa.
Thanks, Kenneth. So every year, the Auditor-General publishes the annual work program. So that sets out the key focus areas across our financial and performance audits. So this year, the key themes were efficiency and the optimal use of public resources. So we're particularly interested in how agencies, councils are using data and analytics to gain better insights into their operations and to improve decision-making and identify opportunities to reduce waste. Another area of focus is grants administration. So we'll be looking at agencies that administer grants, as well as the grant recipients, focusing on governance, accountability, whether funding is spent as intended, and delivering the expected outcomes.
Infrastructure, major capital projects also continue to be an area of focus. So given the scale of government investment in projects, we'll be looking at governance arrangements, procurement practices and contract management. Also focusing on energy transition. So that's how the public sector is managing climate risks and opportunities and supporting the transition to renewable energies. And we also have a First Nations people performance audit. Program. So as part of that work, we'll be undertaking our first place-based audit. So that's looking at how government services are coordinated and delivered within a community or geographical area. So if you're interested in learning more, the annual work program is available on our website.
So every year, the Auditor-General publishes a local government sector report to Parliament. So that brings together the results and observations from all 150 councils across New South Wales. So the next report will be released early next year. So that will highlight findings from our 25-26 financial audits. So it includes insights on financial reporting, sustainability, internal controls, conflicts of interest, procurement, IT, cyber and artificial intelligence. So the report basically provides a sector-wide perspective on the common challenges, the better practices and areas where councils can strengthen governance and accountability. Next slide. So we also have a number of performance audits in the pipeline for local government.
So we'll be looking at areas such as long-term financial planning, so whether councils are setting themselves up for long-term sustainability. We'll also look at the effectiveness of audit, risk and improvement committees, how infrastructure contributions are managed, and the delivery of waste management services as well. Next slide. We also have audits planned on major capital projects, procurement practices and support for regional town water infrastructure. So collectively, these audits will focus on how well councils are planning for the future, how councils are managing public resources, delivering services and infrastructure to the communities. So before I finish, I'd just like to thank everyone involved in the audit.
It was a very smooth process, and it's really pleasing that the accounts were signed and lodged ahead of the statutory deadline. So yeah, thanks again for inviting us to the meeting, and we're happy to answer any questions if there's any.
Thank you, Larissa and Kenneth, for that presentation. I think there could be some councillor questions. Are there any questions, councillors? No, there isn't. I'm surprised. I thought there would be. Well, thank you very much for that. We will thank you for the work done with the audit, and we will now move to our debate. Stay on. Yeah, you're welcome to stay and watch if you like. Otherwise, you can go . Thank
Other than to thank the presenters for it, I spent a bit of time with our finance officers this afternoon to clarify some of the, I guess, my interpretation or misinterpretation of what was there, and thank the staff for their time.
Thank you, Councillor Sheather. Any further questions? No further discussion. Right of reply not necessary. I'll put the motion, all those in favour? That is unanimous and absent from the chamber—I should have said that before—but absent from the chamber is Councillor Dogramaci and Councillor Creed.
10.4.2 — CS - September 2026 Quarterly Budget Review Statement
Official meeting record
Council decision and source documents
Outcome: Carried
249 Resolution
RESOLVED on the motion of Councillor Sheather seconded by Councillor Veigel.
That Council receive the information contained in this report regarding the September 2026 Quarterly Budget Review, and that the Budget adjustments, resulting in a bottom line surplus of $954K, as summarised in the report and detailed in Attachment 1 to the report, be adopted.
Good evening, Mayor, Councillors and staff. Almost exactly a year ago, I asked Council not to proceed with an SRV and asked that whatever you decided, you fix the basics: real savings, a ring fence renewal ledger, hardship support and fairer rates. Council applied and IPART approved, and I respect that process. Tonight, as a ratepayer now paying that SRV, I'd like to check in on those basics. I acknowledge the work of staff and the auditors, but the papers tell a harder story. Cash. At 30 September, Council's internal reserves were $12.1 million more than the unrestricted cash available to back them. The budget review itself calls this a negative unrestricted cash position, yet the cover report says there are no material financial concerns.
Councillors deserve to see that in the report itself. The audit. The draft statements showed a $21.7 million surplus before capital grants. After the audit, $5.5 million. The main reason is a $14 million jump in the estimated tip cleanup cost, now counted as an expense, including the old McGrath's Hill plant. That bill is now $27 million, more than three times last year's. This quarter moves $2 million towards that, which is a good start, but that still leaves a gap of over $20 million with no clear funding plan. The SRV. Tonight's quarterly review covers the first three months of SRV income, and it has no SRV line mentioned. IPART requires Council to report every year until 2034-2035 on how money is spent, and its report notes that Council didn't meet the reporting conditions of its 2022 and 2023 variation.
A quarterly ledger is the simplest way to get this right from year one. The long-term plan. Council's own plans—sorry, Council's own long-term financial plan shows that even with the full SRV, operating deficits return from 2031. Renewal spending never reaches the benchmark, and unrestricted cash runs out by 2035-36. The plan also leaves out the tip liability, Council's actual borrowings, and the running costs of the new West Invest-funded facilities. The community begrudgingly accepted a 39% rate rise on the promise of sustainability. Council's own plans don't yet meet that promise. Savings and fairness. The comprehensive spending review promised with the SRV targeted a million dollars a year.
That represents under 1% of Council's total spending. Council hasn't published what each line item saves, and one, a vacancy discount, sits in this year's budget at $881,000. But that's a saving that disappears once those positions are filled. Compare that with residents. Your own capacity-to-pay study found residential rates were here, were on the higher end of comparable councils, with Richmond, Windsor the most vulnerable. The savings are small, but the burden on households is not. I'm not here to relitigate the SRV, although it probably sounds like I am, but to make it accountable. Tonight I ask Council to report on the SRV every quarter. Include SRV income received, SRV-funded renewal spending, and the balance carried forward.
Report unallocated cash cleanly in every budget review cover report, positive or negative. Funding the tip liability. Report on what drove the increase, when the money is needed, and how the $27 million will be funded. Four. Present the updated long-term plan and rating review together, including actual debt, the tip liability, West Invest-funded assets, running costs, and options to ease the residential burden before the draft 27-28 budget is exhibited in April and before you decide whether or not you'll levy the full second-year increase. None of these costs much, but all of these items build trust, and trust is what the community said it needed when you asked us to pay more. Thank you for your time and for your service to the Hawkesbury.
Thank you, Tim. Are you happy to take any questions ? Yes. Any questions for Mr Corcoran? No questions. Thank you very much, guys. Thank you. Would someone like to move something ? Move Councillor Sheather. The
Yeah, Madam Mayor, I wondered if the staff probably didn't have time to take the notes, but a lot of the notes, a lot of the items that were discussed, I discussed with the finance officers today, and they might like to touch on some of them. Would
I might ask through the acting general manager to Chief Financial Officer to explain some of those things. Thank you, Shiggy. On the TIP would be the first one, yeah.
Through you, Madam Mayor. So the landfill site, the $14 million, so that was done through the relevant accounting standards, AASB 137116 and the AASB Interpretation 1. So the accounting treatment for the tip remediation provision remeasurement, the adjustment to the tip remediation provision represents a remeasurement of an existing remediation obligation to reflect the revised estimate of the expenditure required to settle the obligation. In accordance with AASB 137, provisions are required to be reviewed at each reporting date. And adjusted to reflect the current best estimate of the obligation. Consideration was also given to WSB 116 and AASB Interpretation 1, which provide guidance on the circumstances in which changes in existing restoration and remediation liabilities may be recognised as adjustments to the carrying amount of the associated asset.
The remeasurement was not recognised as an addition to the TIP remediation asset because the adjustment did not qualify for further capitalisation against a related asset under the requirements of WSB Interpretation 1, meaning we had to take it to the income statement. Accordingly, the increase in the provision was recognised as an expense in the income statement, with the corresponding increase recognised against remediation provision in the statement of financial position. The crucial thing here is that the increase in provision is not a cash item that is recorded in the financials, and the other crucial thing is that when those provisions are to be carried out or to be paid, Council will have to consider the strategy , the domestic waste strategy, on how to fulfil that provision in whatever time period that it's required to do so.
Through you, Madam Mayor. So in terms of the unrestricted cash of $405, 000 as at 30th of June 26, it's very important to note that the internal allocations is at $35 million, and that's at Council's disposal to dissolve all of those internal allocations at any given point in time should it be required. Also— It stands that Council does have $35 million that is subject not to external restrictions, that it can reserve for particular projects that is spending in line with whatever their resolve to do so. So it is pleasing to see that we do have $35 million to put towards projects for the community.
Yeah, thanks, Madam Mayor. Madam Mayor, in relation, when I was Mayor, I asked for a graph to put up in relation to what the speaker spoke of and that transparency of the rate increase. Were we proposing to do that at around the time the quarterly reports were done or in some other process? It's still happening, I would hope.
Laurie Mifsud(staff - Director Corporate Services)
Through you, Madam Mayor, yes, those graphs are currently being prepared, and once we've prepared those, we should be able to prepare those for each quarter.
So that would be a quarterly report on the special rate variation of what has been taken in and what has been spent and on which projects. Is that correct?
Thanks for the clarification of that, Madam Mayor. The other thing when we spoke of it, the community made very clear that, and we did in relation to the rate increase, that it was going to be used for infrastructure and predominantly roads. And going through the assessment with our finance officers that I do regularly, 78% of the rate increase in the last financial year went into roads. 78%. And the rest was infrastructure programs. And some of those programs have been already distributed to us and are publicly available in relation to the works that have been done. And it depends on the cost of those. It was explained to us earlier that the rise or fall in those projects depends on the costing of jobs as they go. But in relation to the costing that we did at the time, those roads and projects are all available. Thanks very much, Madam Mayor.
Thank you, Councillor Sheather. Any further discussion? No further discussion. I'd just like to thank the speaker for raising the questions that were raised. I think it's really important that when people feel strongly about what they may perceive as missing information within our financial documents, that they come in here and they ask the questions in this chamber so that we can put any additional reporting or any additional information that explains it better to the public, so that the public have the— Correct and accurate information out there. I would just like to touch on one thing that Mr Corcoran said about the non-reporting of the 2022-23 special rate variation, just to clarify that was not the infrastructure variation.
That was the rate peg additional amount to take us up to a level to sustain council operations. Just to make that clear, I think I'm correct on that. So if there's no further discussion on that, a right of reply, Councillor Sheather? Not necessary. All those in favour? Unanimous, with Councillor Dogramaci and Councillor Creed absent.
8.1.1 — MM1 – NSW Government’s Proposed Changes to Local Infrastructure Contributions
Official meeting record
Council decision and source documents
Outcome: Carried
241 Resolution
RESOLVED on the motion of the Mayor, Councillor Lyons-Buckett.
That Council:
1. Note the NSW Government's 6 November 2026 announcement that it plans to permanently defer payment of developer contributions for essential community infrastructure from the Construction Certificate to the Occupation Certificate stage and potentially redirect billions of dollars already paid to Councils.
2. Write to the NSW Premier, Minister for Planning and Public Spaces and the Member for Hawkesbury, Ms Robyn Preston MP:
- a) Setting out the local impacts of this proposed reform,
- b) Asking that the NSW Government abandon the proposed reform, and
- c) Calling on the NSW Government to work in partnership with Councils to deliver the housing, infrastructure and quality of life that our communities deserve.
3. Submit a late motion to Local Government NSW calling for the NSW Labor Government to abandon the proposed reform to the timing of collection of developer contributions and to instead work in partnership with Councils to deliver the housing, infrastructure and quality of life our communities deserve prior to the occupation of new dwellings.
We'll move on to the next item, which is item 8.1.1, which is the Mayoral Minute, which I shall move and speak to. It is fairly comprehensively outlined what that is about. It stems from an announcement by the state government on the 6th of November regarding plans to defer payment of developer contributions for essential community infrastructure from the construction certificate to the occupation certificate stage. So that potentially redirects billions of dollars already paid to councils, so not necessarily to our council, but to the sector overall. So when we look at this, we need to be very clear about who should carry the cost of growth. Why should councils and our ratepayers carry the financing cost of infrastructure required because of new development, simply to protect a developer's cash flow?
Developers undertake projects to generate a return. If financing is required to meet the cost of providing infrastructure associated with the development, that cost should not simply be transferred to councils and ultimately to our existing ratepayers. Our communities already carry significant infrastructure backlogs, and we know that was a reason we needed an SRV, and increasing costs of financing, maintaining and replacing essential infrastructure. Cost shifting another burden onto the rate base is neither fair nor sustainable. We should not be prioritising the cash flow of developers over financial sustainability of councils and the interests of the communities that we represent. We know we need more housing, and we know we have constraints in this LGA around delivering that housing.
But any growth we do have must be accompanied by the infrastructure needed to support it, and those who benefit commercially from the development should be the ones carrying the financial cost of delivery, not our ratepayers. Deferring these developer contributions is not a good move. An alternative such as that put forward by Local Government New South Wales around an interest-free loan facility for councils to deliver infrastructure would be much more palatable and much more workable. This proposal does not expect the state to fund the infrastructure; rather, it offers bridging-type finance, with the developer donations ultimately repaying the loans. Local Government New South Wales is working on this issue, and it is an important conversation that needs to be had.
The announcement on November the 6th by the government stated its objective was to reduce upfront costs for housing developments and help developers build homes sooner. Whereas that may be a legitimate policy objective, its design to increase housing supply, the proposed method is unsustainable in the expectation that councils must manage the financial consequences of receiving future contributions later, rather than at the stage that they receive them now. The transfer of responsibility and risk from developers to local government and ultimately to our ratepayers, with some vague promises that the state may assist in certain circumstances, is unwelcome by the local government sector. I urge councillors to support this minute, which supports expressing our thoughts on this proposal, seeking to have it abandoned and calling on the New South Wales Government to work in partnership in the most effective way with councils to ensure infrastructure is delivered.
This proposal does not do that. It gives an added burden to local government, and we are urging councillors to be part of the advocacy to have this changed to a more sustainable method. Thank you. Any discussion? Councillor Sheather. Question
Madam Mayor. Yeah . An example: the Redbank development and the bridge across the Grose was started at 25 million. Now it's up 48, I think. If there was, if there was an arrangement, as the Minister is proposing, what would be the obligation where a costing was made some years ago for 25 million and, as the process went on, it doubled in price pretty well? How is council supposed to wave a magic wand and know what things are going to be doubled in, what was it, five or six years? What would be the implications to Council where there was decisions made in relation to voluntary agreements and over time that they weren't a double, as this would be? I'll get some clarity on
That because that was a voluntary planning agreement and it wasn't a figure for the bridge build. It was a figure in lieu of the bridge being built, so it wasn't the cost of the bridge. But I'll pass to the Director of Planning for comment.
Through you, Madam Mayor, funds agreed upon under a voluntary planning agreement are slightly different to what this change would encompass. But the impact that this change has is, for example, if Council is using contributions funds to acquire land for public open space or stormwater infrastructure, and we're acquiring it at a particular rate and collecting contributions at a slightly lower rate, which is the case, the impact of this change will mean that Council will receive those contributions collected at a later stage. So there'll be a further financial impost on Council.
Thank you, Madam Mayor. I'm not going to support this Mayoral Minute for a few reasons. Before I start to address those reasons, I'd just like to say that when I contested the state election in 2023, I was briefed by the shadow ministers at the time about the state of housing in New South Wales, and back then— There was a shortfall of 134,000 dwellings. That was a forecast. That was over five years. And while that was, I mean, that's a very big number of dwellings that we need to build. But the most staggering statistic, which wasn't an estimate, was the number of people waiting for social housing, and it was 56,000. 56,000 people in 2023 were on the waiting list for social and public housing.
Now that is a sobering problem, and it's— we should all own this problem. I know the state government has carriage of it, but it is up to all of us to try and address that particular problem. The social housing, unfortunately, has risen by nearly 30%. So there's now 73,000 or so people waiting for public housing. We haven't reached, as a state, we haven't reached or got anywhere near the target that we wanted to reach. And this is why I'm not going to support this Mayoral Minute, even though I think that some of the things that have been mentioned are probably quite legitimate. But I think we have to look at this from a different perspective. We have to get more people, more builders building housing.
Now , developers, by pulling this lever of giving developers a little bit of leeway in the risks that they take to undergo these projects, may very well speed up the delivery of houses. I think that we have to also be mindful that the New South Wales Auditor-General's report actually highlighted that there were a few councils that were quite, I think their words were deficiencies in how they planned and delivered on the contributions that they had received. So there was need for some tweaking of that. I think that also we have to be mindful that we don't have any specific Hawkesbury evidence. And while we don't have that, I think it's pretty dangerous to make a position that we don't actually adopt, well, that we don't agree with this actual lever .
I think that that's not a good position to take without evidence. So I think a better approach would be for Council to request an assessment of the actual financial implications for the Hawkesbury, examine the potential benefits and risks, and identify appropriate... Before we adopt a definitive position, I think this would send a message to our community that we are actually willing to work with the state government and provide them with that data so that they know what they are dealing with, and we truly do collaborate. I think that we really have to make sure that we understand that the deferment of this, of the payment of contributions, may very well not be as great as being made out, and there's been commentary that it will be billions of dollars.
In the Hawkesbury's case, it might not be that much, and it might be a lesser amount that we just have to balance whether that is actually a risk and it's unacceptable. I've run out of time. Thank
Thank you, Madam Mayor. I support the Mayor's mayoral minute. I thank her for bringing it. It really is the most nakedly cynical hypocrisy on the part of the state government, and I can't bring myself to agree with Councillor Kotlash. Working with the state government, if you're in local government, feels like going up to Dracula and saying, I'd like to work with you about how much blood you'd like to take out of my neck. I did some digging and worked out what Labor campaigned on. Only a few years ago, and it bears to remember this, Paul Scully, who's currently the planning minister, said in 2023 that any proposal to defer or delay payment of infrastructure contributions from developers is not costless in terms of the budget, is not costless in terms of infrastructure delivery.
And then he went on to make a more direct statement. He said, and I quote, A delay in the collection of infrastructure contributions equates to a delay in the delivery of infrastructure. This is what Labor campaigned on only a few years ago. As though to drive that point home, the current Treasurer, Daniel Mookhey, said when he was announcing his first budget to the Parliament, If we don't build the streets, no one will build the homes. It seemed fairly clear to them when they were asking to be elected that there was this common sense understanding that we were always on the back foot, and that families can move into a suburb in the prospect of sending their kids to a school that hasn't been built yet, and that their kids would reach high school before the local primary school would even be built.
And we have gone to too many conferences to say infrastructure has to come first. So to propose a mechanism that effectively cost shifts that to a sector that's already strapped, to know that we have in the form of our state minister for local government somebody who is not a partner to local government. But who is nakedly contemptuous of the local government sector, and is always wagging his finger at us and imposing restrictions on us that diminish not only our agency, but our ability to even meet and be briefed about matters of consequence, I think is something that deserves to be complained about loudly, and I— I expect that that will be a loud theme at the coming LGNSW conference. Thank you.
Yeah, thank you, Madam Mayor. Thank you for your motion, by the way. I fully support it. It takes my breath away to a point where somebody in the bureaucracy can actually sit down and say, Oh, we'll just delay the payments to council until an occupancy certificate is issued. Are they fair dinkum? The best thing they probably built was a Lego, and I doubt even that. The lag is what you've mentioned in your motion. It would be tremendous. You expect councils to go and finance this stuff. Are they serious? The Deputy Mayor has exactly dead set right that, you know, you don't build the roads and infrastructure, you're not going to build the home, right? And this is where it's going to. We're on a precipice, right, of our housing building industry.
It's going to the wall next year because a number of builders have warned their tradies, pay off your debt, boys, because the pipeline's getting particularly thin. Two of the builders is Allam and the other one is McDonald Jones. They're not the only ones. Only today another builder has gone bust with the residential blocks in Sydney, not to mention the very, I can't think, Bathurst that went broke for, what, three billion dollars' worth. I don't know how we do it, really, when we're shackled by a state government, or anybody, not just at the state government, or the bureaucrats that are advising them to do this. What do they want, the money in the banks so they can earn, what, five percent interest rate in the short-term money market and they can go and put it somewhere else?
Bugger if I know. But I thank you for the motion. I'll be supporting it.
Thank you, Councillor Veigel. Councillor Wheeler. Thanks, Madam Mayor. I wonder if you would be willing to add point three to your motion, and I've sent some words through to the staff, that we submit a late motion to Local Government New South Wales calling on the New South Wales Labor Government to abandon its proposed reform and to instead work in partnership with councils to deliver the housing infrastructure and quality of life our communities deserve prior to occupation of new buildings. You'll see that I have shamelessly stolen your words from the rest of the motion .
I'm happy to include that. I wasn't able—I was hoping to ask Councillor Creed had the Local Government New South Wales Board submitted a motion, which they may well have, but I couldn't find that out. So I'm happy to include that. Obviously, we can still go through the process of submitting a late motion. I'm not sure what happens if one's already in, but I assume ours would lapse. But I'm happy to include that. Thank you, Councillor Wheeler. You speak
To it. I did ask another friend of mine who is on the LG New South Wales Board, and she wasn't aware of a motion. But if there are others, and it's possible that there are, then I think ours just is added to the group of similar motions, and one will lead, and the rest will just be sucked into the grab bag of things that say the same thing. Councillor Veigel and Councillor Sheather have already highlighted, and Councillor Zamprogno have already highlighted some of the problems with this. I do note that Minister Hoenig did style himself as Dracula in a recent Halloween meme. I will make no further comment. Well, a bit of truth in advertising at least. We're talking about—look, if you have a look back through the documents that are presented in this business paper, particularly the annual report that talks about the infrastructure that we've delivered.
But also, you know, the reports that talk about how we fund that infrastructure, and you look at the infrastructure around Vineyard, which is the space that we're in at the moment, we already know that existing ratepayers are carrying the can for that development because the developer contributions simply aren't big enough to provide the infrastructure in that area. Now, that's unfortunately the norm for councils these days. We're talking about no contribution at all from developers until occupancy certificates are signed. You know, we've got people who move into houses and never get an occupancy certificate. I know they're not supposed to, but that's the space that councils have to function in.
I think it would be worth me reading out a quote from Rose Jackson, the relevant minister at the Country Mayors Association last week, where she said, and I quote, I got a lot of feedback from developers that this will get housing moving. They, meaning the developers, have indicated it would be useful for them. So we've got a minister who has consulted with developers but not councils. It takes years for us to accumulate enough money to provide infrastructure, and that money is paid for not by the developer, but by the people who buy these houses, the people who paid for infrastructure that we're still waiting to be delivered at Pitt Town. That wasn't the developer of Pitt Town. It was the people who borrowed that money to pay for the mortgages of those houses who will be paying that money off for 30 years.
That doesn't belong in the developers' coffers, in the developers' bank account earning interest. It belongs with the people who have to deliver the infrastructure, these days council. If developers don't have to pay for it till the last minute, then ratepayers will continue to carry the can until they do. What if the developer goes broke? What if they cut and run? We already know what this looks like. We see it at Hawkesbury Hospital. We see it at our pools on Windsor and Richmond Road, in our childcare centres, in the schools making do with demountables. We know in Western Sydney what a lack of reasonable infrastructure contribution looks like. None of this is going to build social housing.
The state and federal government will is what's required to build social and affordable housing, not developer contributions. The information that's come through from Local Government New South Wales around the scale of this infrastructure, Blacktown City Council reported in 2024 a $631 million unfunded capital cost for community infrastructure. Penrith, the St Marys Precinct alone, $235 million, $108 million for roads. Now we know what that looks like because we sit on some of those roads in the morning. Camden Council in June 2025 held $175 million in infrastructure contributions earmarked to support development and population growth. That's money that they can use to deliver. What happens if it's sucked in by developers?
When does council get to deliver that stuff? What we're saying to people is you can have a house, but you can't have the infrastructure that makes living in that house tolerable until after you've moved in. So then by the time we deliver it, how long are you in that house? How long have you got that traffic jam? How long have you got ambulances ramping in A and E waiting for the infrastructure to be delivered by different levels of government? Five years? Ten years? When is it acceptable? We're not—we're building. Developers might build houses. We're the ones who are asked, who are requested to give people some sort of liveable community. We can't do that if we have the money so, so late in the pipeline.
Thank you, Councillor Wheeler. Councillor McMahon. Thank you, Madam Mayor. I fully support your Mayoral Minute. I thank you for bringing it. It's a sad reality that it's just another item in a long line of items of this current state government screwing us over. I think that's the only way that I can put it, to be so blunt. Macquarie Street is completely operating in a silo where they are not listening to not only the local community, but they clearly, especially through their Minister for Local Government, do not give a damn about local councils across New South Wales. We are constantly being punished, and when you look at the debate that we have had just this year about a rate rise, a special rate variation, and the things that we've had to contemplate and decide upon for our community, these broader things that happen beyond our reach , beyond our involvement by the state government are part of the bigger set of reasons of why we have to consider things like a rate rise, because we're constantly getting hit by the state government to cop more and more where we have to fund that gap, and we just can't keep funding that gap.
There is a very limited pool of funds available, and to do this one to us, and Councillor Wheeler was right, to put it so further down the path of when we would get those contributions to deliver the infrastructure to the community is just such a kick in the teeth. It's absolute madness. It is just one thing, as I said, after another, and— I don't think it's sustainable with the current trajectory of the state government into how much they want to hurt and damage local councils. It is such an insult to us. So, on the other hand, we need developers. It's an inevitable thing that we need in the community. Governments cannot fund housing on their own, state and federal. They just can't do it. There needs to be a private capacity.
It's a commercial reality. There needs to be people investing in the housing market to deliver stock. But we cannot allow something like this to happen where we have to put into our own pocket, pockets that are already empty, to deliver to our community the very basics of what those developments impose on our local area. So thank you, Madam Mayor, for bringing this. I fully support it. I think that we should make a motion this weekend at Wollongong about it and let the state government know exactly how we feel. Thank you.
Thank you, Madam Mayor, and thank you for bringing this mayoral minute up too. Look, I read through the notes and did a little bit myself. State government is still getting their money up front. Wow. So it must be very important, and then we're put to the back of the list. And it's going to really—they only address the cash flow issues that we're going to have with this, with our ratepayers, the escalating cost, the costs of legal fees when these people go broke. Imagine what that battle would have been. They were $4.2 billion. Now, if they would have had hold of council money with this suggestion, where would that have gone? It would have escalated something unbelievable. So councils really, we have to stand up and say enough's enough, because we will only have our ratepayers funding all these developers.
Infrastructure, and honestly , I think the state government has done that many backflips lately. I think we're going to see them up in Brisbane in the Olympics, to be honest, in the gymnastics, because this is another one they've got to backflip on. Because when the people really find out what this is going to cost them, it's bad enough down the vineyard now, there's, I can't see too many parks and that now. Imagine if we said to those people, you have to even wait longer. You've got to wait longer till the developer decides, well, we're finished. I've seen parts where the developer has to deliver 346 lots before he has to move forward with the infrastructure like parks and that. So he delivered 340 and left the other ones hanging there for years.
This is— they're saying the other plan we have isn't a good plan. You don't replace a plan that's not good with a worse one, with a terrible one. I think this has got to go back to them and say, rethink it, because you're paying a lot of really well-educated people a lot of good money to make some dumb decisions, and this is really dumb. I could say some other words around that. So look, I'll be supporting you, Madam Mayor, and I'll be going down and hopefully we can push a few of the buttons down in Wollongong next week. Appreciate it. Thank you.
Thank you, Councillor Ryan. Any further discussion? Thank you, councillors, for that input. I think what it symbolises is that we are the level of government that is always hit with the backlogs because we have these things imposed on us from a level of government to which we are under the control of. So we have to push back through advocating and putting out our displeasure about these sort of things. The state government has no hesitation in pitting councils against developers rather than supporting an initiative that would actually facilitate a cooperative approach. So local government New South Wales has put forward a proposal, which is a proactive model around a five million dollar interest-free loan facility that would enable councils to access interest-free loans if they had to do it, rather than councils having to finance the required infrastructure.
So that's separate to my mayoral minute, but that is a proposal that exists, and we know that that's just one of the approaches that could give a better balance to how this goes on, rather than this massively divisive sort of proposal that really I just can't see how it equates to any more housing. It just simply does not, because the housing wouldn't have the support around it. It definitely does nothing to indicate it would equate to any increase in social or public housing, because the government's not proposing to put any further development through this proposal. And so the simple bottom line is we cannot afford it. No council can. afford to be carrying the burden of financing infrastructure when there is an increase in development and they have to provide that infrastructure.
So the deferral of the payments until the occupation certificate stage is not feasible, and it's just an additional threat to the financial sustainability of the local government sector. So I thank Councillor Wheeler for that addition. We can get that late motion in and see how we go with that. And we shall now vote on the Mayoral Minute. All those in favour? Councillor McMahon, Councillor Wheeler, Councillor Ryan, Councillor Zamprogno, Councillor Sheather, Councillor Veigel, Councillor Reardon, Councillor Djuric, Councillor Lyons-Buckett, against? Councillor Kotlash, absent from the chamber? Councillor Dogramaci and Councillor Creed.
RESOLVED on the motion of Mayor, Councillor Lyons-Buckett.
That Council:
1. Set the schedule of Ordinary Council Meetings for 2027, as outlined in this report.
2. Set the time of Ordinary Council Meetings for 2026 to generally commence at 6:30pm and to take place in the Council Chambers, or by audio-visual link in accordance with Council's Code of Meeting Practice.
| 12 | 2027 Hypro Sydney Sheepdog Trial | Sydney Sheepdog Club Incorporated | $875 | 27/03/2027 | 51 | Yes |
| 13 | Jacaranda Convention | Lions Club of Richmond Inc | $950 | 12/11/2027 | 52 | Yes |
| 14 | Paws with A Cause | Hawkesbury Community Outreach Services | $1,175 | 25/02/2027 | 57 | Yes |
2. Approve the execution of Council's standard Sponsorship Agreement for the applications numbered 3 to 14 as identified in Table 1 and Attachment 1 of this report.
3. Advise successful applicants that the approved sponsorship amount is inclusive of in-kind support from Council for the holding of the event, exclusive of marketing support and promotion through Council's social media channels.
4. Advise applicants, Hawkesbury High School numbered 1 in Attachment 1 and Kurrajong and North Richmond Anglican Church numbered 2 in Attachment 1, that their applications for event sponsorship were not successful in accordance with the Event Sponsorship Assessment Criteria Matrix and invite discussions with Council Officers to support future funding applications.
Item 10.2.1, the event sponsorship. Hang on, I've just lost my call-up page. What have I done with it? Here we are. Event sponsorship. Councillor Wheeler— oh, sorry, Councillor Ryan has a declaration to make for that. Thank you, Councillor Ryan.
Yeah, thank you, Madam Mayor. I am actually the chairman of the Pitt Town ANZAC Day Planning Committee, which is mentioned in this report, and I will leave the chamber.
Councillor Wheeler, could you just turn Councillor microphones— Councillor Ryan's microphone off? Councillor microphones, Ryan off. And would you like to move something, or not? No. No. Okay. Would someone like— Councillor Sheather and Councillor Reardon, what are you moving? Okay. Councillor Reardon has moved the recommendation, seconded by Councillor Sheather. Discussion? No. Any discussion?
Councillor Wheeler. Thanks, Madam Mayor. Again, I'm concerned that our criteria isn't serving us well. I'm not sure why we're sponsoring something that carries the name of a pet food company, and we're not sponsoring an inclusive games event for high school kids or a community carols event that brings the community together. So we're sponsoring things that directly involve business, but not sponsoring community in a community events assessment. And I find this troubling, and I can't continue to support these outcomes.
Thank you, Councillor Wheeler. You're not moving something; you're just expressing. Thank you. Any further discussion? No further discussion. Right of reply, Councillor Reardon. Just so that the Hypro one is the Sydney Sheepdog Club. Yes. It's more than pet food. I think Councillor Wheeler may have meant that Hypro is a pet food company.
Madam Mayor. Thank you. I shall put the motion in the business paper. All those in favour? Councillor Kotlash, Councillor McMahon, Councillor Zamprogno, Councillor Sheather, Councillor Veigel, Councillor Reardon, Councillor Djuric, Councillor Lyons-Buckett against? Councillor Wheeler. The motion is carried. Oh, yeah . Gone to our next item. Oh , my son's FaceTiming me. Sorry.
RESOLVED on the motion of Councillor Zamprogno seconded by Councillor Veigel.
That Council adopt the Annual Report 2025/2026, included as Attachment 1 to this report, and complete all required notifications under the Local Government Act, 1993.
Thank you, Madam Mayor. We roll around yet again to our annual report, a substantial piece of work, and congratulations to staff. It's the tapestry of our community writ large. One comment that I would like to make is colleagues would remember earlier in the year. I was opining that it was difficult to find in an annual report or a financial report a clear indication as to Council's level of debt. And I challenged everybody. I said, Do you even know how much debt that we're in? Because if you want to dig through that, you've got to dig fairly deep and look for some obscure terminology in the annual financial reports. I'd like to acknowledge that there is now a brief section in the annual report that relates to debt, so it is an improvement, but it's only about ten lines.
I had hoped that in delivering a section in the annual report about debt that we would not only talk about the level of debt, but also how it's changed over time, what the debt is being put towards, and how our Council compares to its peers. Now, if you were to look at page 19 of the annual report, it does give the quantum of debt, and it does specify, in a sense, the way that that debt is broken down. It doesn't say anything about how we compare to our peers, and it doesn't say anything about how that debt has changed over time. So I'll grade this as a B plus, which is to say more work needed. I would very much like to see a more expansive section that covers the other material that I was referring to.
We've spent less time informing the public about our level of debt than we have informing the public about how we are not a member of the international slave trade on page 66. So in terms of the relative priority, I simply make that observation and finish . Thank you.
Madam Mayor, I too would commend the staff. Quite often there's comments made about lack of information provided, and that everything that we do is in this document in some form of both costing and the position where they sit within our structures and the likes. And while some of it might not be what people want to see, if people are interested in council business, there's assessment in relation to things we've got to do and where we sit, our responsibilities, opportunities. It's all in there. How many meetings we attend, the whole lot is in there. And for someone who would like to, when they've got nothing better to do on a rainy day, have a look at some documents, I would suggest that they could be well informed on council's position in a lot of ways by taking a little bit of time to have a look at this document.
There's a lot of work goes into it. We've got to do it. It's a part of, again, of our responsibilities. And it would be, I guess, a shame that that information is made available and in too many cases that opportunity is not made available. People don't avail themselves to that.
Thank you. I'll put the motion, which is that in the business paper, all those in favour? That's a unanimous vote with Councillor Dogramaci and Councillor Creed absent.
1. Councillor Wheeler. Thanks, Madam Mayor. I'll move the recommendation in the business paper. Yes. A seconder for that? Councillor Reardon, thank you. I did want to highlight a couple of matters. One is the DA 0512/26, which is the resource recovery facility at Woodlands Road, Wilberforce. I find clearly these resource recovery facilities are on the rise. We've had a few applications for them. I think they represent a real problem for LGAs like ours, particularly when the material going to these facilities, and I've raised a similar concern about one proposed for Milham Street, they often involve very heavy vehicle traffic along local roads. That will be the same if it's heading for Woodlands.
So it will go up the guts of Wilberforce on a— A regional road that Council has to pay for. So I would really like to see the reports that are raised about these DAs make note of the impact that vehicles travelling to these facilities have on our roads. I mean, the alternative route is along Old Sackville Road, which is a road even less capable of handling heavy vehicle traffic past the Council depot. Any trucks coming from further up Putty Road come down through Old Sackville, rattle along past all the houses there, down along what is effectively a smear of bitumen on alluvial soil, and down into Woodlands via Sackville Road. This is the difficulty, I think, with having pockets of industrial land in the middle of areas that are either residential or rural residential surrounding them.
And while it's perfectly legitimate for this DA to exist and the facility to exist, there are ongoing impacts on Council and residents around traffic, road and noise. I also point out that Woodlands Road is the main access point for a sporting facility that is heavily used by children in the community, which means that heavy vehicle traffic is not a really good co-location. Can I just also point out that Belmont Park, the planning proposal for which was refused by Council, you can see in the report to Council, is now being taken to the Department of Planning to try their luck using a different option. Hawkesbury residents should be aware that that proposal is not dead yet. Thanks. Thank you, Councillor Wheeler
Sheather. Question, Madam Mayor. Just taking on board the comments made by Councillor Wheeler. When I was mayor, I spoke to the staff about the feasibility of a weight tax. And while we chucked that around, and I guess I put this in the form of a question without notice, that if we were to have a weight fee, say a dollar a tonne, on most products are worth hundreds of dollars a tonne, so it's carted in the trucks . With projects like Cornwallis, we wouldn't have to put rates up in a million years just for a lousy dollar a tonne, the amount of soil that was moved in there. But it's not only the soil. What Councillor Wheeler spoke about in relation to development in our city, there's not much that doesn't happen without truck movements.
And I'm not suggesting that we create a situation at all that would demand a great fee. But we've got quarries that we charge a very minor amount for products that are moved from quarries, but we've got the same trucks that carry other items in our city and pay nothing. I don't see the equality there. But when we asked for rate increases, we went to the public saying that we need to assess every opportunity in relation to bettering our roads. Trucks by far do the most damage, and so I guess. My question, question without notice, is that if we could have some way or a process if we were to proceed with such a proposal of how we might go about that.
Get it tomorrow But thank you. Any further discussion? No further discussion. Right of reply, Councillor Wheeler. Not necessary. Not necessary. All those in favour? Unanimous, with Councillor Dogramaci and Councillor Creed absent from the chamber.
Thanks, Madam Mayor. Just a question before I begin. Have we had any further info regarding bird flu in the LGA? Have we had any cases? Are we aware? Mr Mifsud.
It at all . Thank you. That's really the main concern I was worried about, I suppose, whether it's active yet in the LGA. I know, I think they've had an instance in Campbelltown and a few others. I think this meeting , the Disaster and Emergency Committee meeting, was really useful. I urge people who are concerned about bushfire preparedness particularly to hop onto Council's website and just watch the section of the meeting. It doesn't take very long, but we got a really comprehensive update from both the RFS and the SES, which I found really helpful. Notable things from that: we're now in the fire season. I think most people who have lived here for a while are aware of that, but fire season has well and truly begun.
You need a permit to burn. I think the RFS is already sick of going out and containing your escaped pile burn. They would like some sleep on the weekend. There's also been an increase to the amount of hazard reduction that's been possible this year, which is good, I think, and will hopefully allay some concerns. The other thing that was interesting that came from the RFS is that there's now a district support group, which is a non-frontline group, which is great for people who might want to be involved in the SES but, like me, don't want to get on or are unable to get on a fire truck. So lots of new driving stuff around that in a big incident or even in a slightly smaller incident means that firefighters can stay on the fireground.
There's also a need for local people to volunteer with both the RFS and the SES. If people have some time on their hands and they're looking for something to do that is more worthwhile than getting sucked into the social media void, you could join the RFS or the SES. Lovely people, lots of fun things to be had. Some really useful discussions as well around evacuation routes and heatwave response that I think we as a council should continue to follow up on. Another question, if I may: have we got any update on the Local Government New South Wales emergency management training that was mentioned in that meeting? I note from the report that we are all keen to go. Yes, we
Are Thank you, Maxine. I'll have to take that on notice. I haven't heard of anything, but I'll follow it up. Thanks. Thank you for that further discussion.
Yeah, I made a contact with, I think it was Transport. I was given a number. It's in relation to the guideposts at Sackville Ferry, and I expect the other ones are the same. They've got water heights on them, and they're in error. They're supposed to indicate, as the signs do along the road, the depth of water at that position, and they're way too low. There's the three metre indicator on the post is about two metres off the water. I've been around a little while. I know what high tide is, but if there's anybody given any indications of water heights... That are reading those levels, they're wrong. And it's been noted by other people that they're wrong, even with transport, but they have not been changed.
And I've been on this for about 12 months, so I don't know what the process is, but can we do that through our correspondence with whoever's responsible for that, or do we need to go somewhere else?
I imagine we would have to find the appropriate authority to deal with that, but that can be taken on notice. And, yeah , we'll just do a request for that to be investigated.
Yeah, Madam Mayor, I sat at the meeting there and listened to it. One thing that I did pick up was that we've got to start educating our people both in fire and flood. We have these get ready for fire days. We have one out where I live, and we're flood affected and fire affected. I'd be suggesting that we put them together with SES and the RFS, and perhaps we could get some form of transport and take the people for a drive along these evacuation routes, because I get constantly asked, Where do we go? And the second question is, When we get there, what do we do? And I think we've got to fill these holes in because people don't know the... We show them the blue signs, and a lot of them say, Geez, I wondered what they were for.
They're the ones you're followed to go out in flood. But I think if we could take these people on a journey along those evacuation routes, be them in wherever, and they can see them firsthand. And I think firsthand knowledge for these people is far greater than looking at it on a map or in the middle of the night, it's roaring down raining and you're looking for a blue sign. Thank you, Mayor, if we could take that on. Thank you
Councillor Ryan. That's a really good point, and I know years ago in the flood committee we were discussing about doing just that. But the Director of Planning has just said that the Hubs Coordinator can do that sort of thing. So maybe if we bring that either as a notice of motion or to the next Disaster and Emergency Management meeting, we can have that organised, because that would be very valuable education for those who want to know more about that. Any further discussion? No further discussion. Councillor Wheeler, right of reply? Not necessary. All those in favour? Unanimous. Councillor Dogramaci, Councillor Creed are absent.
RESOLVED on the motion of Councillor Wheeler seconded by Councillor Veigel.
That Council:
1. Note that glasses fitted with cameras capable of capturing images and recording video have become increasingly prevalent across Australia through low-cost retailers, and that these glasses may be discreetly worn and used for non-consensual and inappropriate filming, creating significant implications, especially for women and children, who are disproportionately affected by the recording and distribution. However, these glasses can be helpful to those with low vision, those experiencing deafness or hearing loss, or those with other accessibility needs.
2. Council further note that the Attorney-General has encouraged councils to take action to restrict the use of camera-equipped eyewear and that other local government areas in Australia have moved to do so.
3. Update Council's conditions of entry and other policies to ban the use of camera-equipped glasses at Council leisure centres, swimming pools, libraries, playgrounds, community centres, and any other Council facilities as deemed appropriate, subject to any necessary carve outs for deaf, vision-impaired, or disabled users, and communicate this change in policy to users and relevant stakeholders, including installing signage as necessary and consider the need to provide relevant staff with training related to camera-equipped glasses use by customers and patrons.
4. Consult with the Access and Inclusion Advisory Committee about any additional adjustments necessary to conditions of entry and other policies pertaining to the use of camera-equipped glasses in the above and any other high privacy areas, and report this information back to Council.
5. Request the Mayor to:
- a) Write to the NSW Attorney General Michael Daley and NSW Privacy Commissioner Sonia Minutillo to advocate for stronger regulations;
- b) Write to the Prime Minister Anthony Albanese, Attorney-General Michelle Rowland, and Privacy Commissioner Carly Kind, to advocate for updates to the Privacy Act to ensure it is fit for purpose and able to respond to the risks of new wearable technology, and for a temporary ban on smart glasses imports, until Australia's privacy and data collection laws are updated to better protect our communities;
<!-- PDF page 2; original PDF page 25; printed page 25 -->
- c) Write to the eSafety Commissioner to request stronger protections against these devices.
Councillor Wheeler. Thanks, Madam Mayor. Look, I think the intention here is clear. I have sent some amended words through. I sent them to the staff and to councillors late this afternoon. Sorry it didn't come through earlier. It was in part the changes were in part to correct what was clearly some mad transcription error on my part in point two, which made very little sense, unfortunately, and I apologise for that. But also the addition of some changes to some words, that track changes is very helpful, thank you. That is not how I sent it through, but that is very useful. So , except that the read is hard to read. So you can see that I have changed, under advice from a member of the community who sent through some additional information, I've dropped the term smart glasses, which can be also attributed to glasses that provide closed captioning and things into the glasses themselves, and been more specific about this being about glasses that are fitted with cameras.
You'll also see in the addition of point four, which is to consult with the Access and Inclusion Advisory Committee about any additional adjustments that are necessary to the conditions of entry or policies pertaining to the use of these glasses in our facilities. And this is an attempt to make sure that we have an adequate carve-out for people who rely on camera assistance within glasses, to make sure that what we're doing is, what we wanted, the purpose of this is to stop people recording without letting people know that they're being recorded, rather than preventing people who use these as some sort of accessibility aid from being able to continue to use those. The information that was sent through that you would have all received an email from Mr Miller with some additional information I felt was too prescriptive in an operational sense, and that the staff were capable of dealing with additional information without Council telling them exactly what to do.
Some of it is beyond our remit as the governing body to to give to staff. So this is largely about making sure that when people go to our facilities, particularly facilities where privacy is important, like our swimming pools, that they feel comfortable that they are not being filmed and that footage isn't taken that can be misused. And we all know how insidious and how damaging that can be. These glasses are really cheap. They're really intrusive, and they're increasingly hard to spot. You can buy them at Kmart. The federal government has made it clear, the Attorney-General, Michelle Rowland, has made it clear that the government will not ban the import of these glasses and has instructed councils to set our own policy.
I really don't think that that's good enough. An employment lawyer, Paul Halloran, highlighted that the implementation of these glasses causes more harm than it does good. And I'll quote him here: This technology appears to exist for one practical reason, in public or workplace settings only, and that's to record people without their knowledge or consent. There's no legitimate justification for that capability that outweighs the very real harm it causes to privacy, dignity and safety. AI smart glasses should be completely banned. The technology is insidious. There's no obvious moment of recording. It's not a flaw in the design. It is a feature for the users. The question we should be asking is not how we regulate them in swimming pools or workplaces, but why we permit them in public spaces at all.
And what I'm asking Council to do is to put in place some systems where our staff have the capacity to say to people, you must not use those in areas where privacy is important to people. Now, that goes not just for pools, but the library as well. The library is also used as a place where people meet with children as a safe location for families. FACS uses it as a meet-up point. Again, those children should not be subjected to filming, and everyone in that space should be aware that filming is not allowed. That's really all this intends to do. Thanks.
Thank you, Madam Mayor. I like this debate because I see the crossover with what I teach. I teach the HSC level computer course, and the syllabus now places an enormous emphasis on analysing the social and ethical implications of the technologies that are increasingly in use, whether it's AI or smart glasses. And I know that Councillor Wheeler's motion comes from a good place, but I do have to caution the chamber and say that this is a solution in search of a problem. There has never been a prosecution brought in Australia. For the misuse of smart glasses. Yes, there have been prosecutions brought for the inappropriate filming of a person without their consent, but they use conventional technologies that we have drawn no exception to here in this chamber: mobile phones, closed-circuit security cameras and the like.
There has never been a recorded instance. of a breach of privacy caused by a pair of smart glasses in Australia that I can find at all. No charge has been brought against any person for that. Nevertheless, this feels a little bit like a moral panic. There are now ten councils in New South Wales alone that have moved in the same way that Councillor Wheeler has moved tonight, and a majority of those have seen fit to pass, you know, that motion. I think it's a copy-paste thing that might be being circulated from council to council, and that's fine. Councillor Wheeler cites in her background information the experience in Brisbane Council, but it's a salutary case. In the case of Brisbane Council, they did not vote to ban smart glasses.
Now, I think a more moderate approach would simply be to acknowledge that council already has a policy relating to privacy , privacy in areas of elevated sensitivity, such as the change rooms at our gymnasia and pools and perhaps in the library or other council facilities. It might be appropriate to update the terms of entry to make it clear that these are some of the technologies that are included in that prohibition against inappropriate use of technology. But I wouldn't go as far as Councillor Wheeler's motion suggests. These glasses are a new technology. When this was debated at Canterbury-Bankstown Council , they were referred to as pervert glasses, and I think there's a kind of a sense that, you know, anybody that uses these technologies is using them for ill intent.
I know that that's not the case. We've got a pair of augmented reality goggles that we bought at home, nothing that we'd wear out in public. But in terms of providing augmented reality, cameras in glasses are something that we're going to see a lot more of, a lot more. Then you might feel that we should be comfortable in passing a ban like this now because it's a niche product. But within the next 12 months, Apple will release a product that have glasses that have cameras in them, and I think their use will become far more widespread. And I don't believe that there is any evidence that there is a widespread misuse of that technology to breach people's privacy. Generally, I think they're used to identify objects, to provide closed captioning, to provide information projected on the inside of the glass about what the person is looking at.
Press the button that says, What is this? and it will translate a sign, for example, if you're travelling overseas. I'm content with the regulations that we already have as a local government, and I don't feel like I want to overreach in this way. I don't think that there's anything in Councillor Wheeler's motion that helps us understand why it's better to regulate the device than the behaviour, how entirely we would enforce a prohibition. I'm glad that there's now a carve-out relating to people with disabilities, and I think to advocate to the federal government about something that's way above our pay grade is the kind of thing that would have most citizens telling us to stick to our knitting.
Yeah, thanks, Madam Mayor. I'd love to think that Councillor Zamprogno was on the ball, but I don't. We had a similar debate about e-bikes here a few years ago, and they're one of the most mischievous things on this planet. When I push my button to speak, what I was going to suggest or ask Councillor Wheeler, that in part four of your motion, you're proposing to go to the advisory committee that we've just set up, and I'd suggest that this be an agenda item, not necessarily interfere with this motion, but it be an agenda item for that committee. Those people are probably best suited to offer advice on how we might go, because I know that our diligent, our staff is, in relation to writing to the bureaucracy that's indicated here, the Minister and Attorney-General and the like.
If we're going to write a letter, then I would want the best information available that may be offered to the chamber through the process that we have, and that's why we've set up the Access Committee to offer that advice. With cameras, as Councillor Zamprogno spoke of, if someone's holding a camera inappropriately to take photos, you can see it. You call people out. With glasses, and it's not that I've taken a like to them. I need the goddamn things. But you don't know, and I don't know enough about them myself, that if it's being sent somewhere else from the glasses, they're smart glasses. I don't know how smart they are, but I suggest they're not rolling a film in front of your eyes. I suggest that it's going into other places.
And so unless you've confronted someone and say, you know, ask , you know, what the purpose, you wouldn't know whether they're turned on or off or what, and that's concerning. I watch some of the shows on TV, the police shows and the like, and there was one on the other night about one of the, I think it was Bondi Beach, and some of the activities are down there, people acting inappropriately. And I'd suggest there's going to be a lot of smart glasses. That's aside from our pools and things where people can expect to go dressed in appropriate fashion for their activities, including young children, to have a good time, and that that time, that if someone acts inappropriately could affect the rest of their life.
And I think if there's an opportunity for us to make comment to minimise that, we should. So I commend Councillor Wheeler's motion.
Madam Mayor. Just very briefly, I'm happy to support the restricting of the secretive recording devices in pools and childcare centres, and I think it's at some stage down the track if we decide that these smart glasses are an important tool in a library, I'm sure we can revisit the matter. But at this stage, I'm happy to support their no summation. Thank you.
Thank you, Madam Mayor. I wish we could do a drum roll because I'm just about to agree with Councillor Zamprogno. But just a question before I start. Have we got any idea how this might set us up for litigation in terms of, well, there's a, well, it could be a lot of things, discrimination against somebody with a disability, and also are we putting ourselves out on a limb banning this technology? Have we done any analysis of this, the legal setting? Mr. Mister.
Maybe— oh no, I was going to say you could take that on notice, but in one way, I'll just continue with what I was going to say. From reading the note by management on this notice of motion, it seemed pretty clear to me that we have reached a kind of a sweet spot. Where we have said what are the things that we aren't happy to have people engaging in, we haven't actually narrowed it down to what sort of device you might use or however you might achieve those things that we, as a council, have deemed unacceptable in these particular public places. I think that's adequate, and I think that, as I said, I think it's a sweet spot, and I know we have to be mindful of protecting people, but we also have to be mindful that you can use a mobile phone to secretly record or photograph somebody.
I mean, that's not that hard to do. I mean, you know, but we're not going to sort of stop people using mobile phones because they've been normalised. I mean, that sort of technology is what we're used to, and I think that it would. And I also think that if you have a situation where somebody who requires these sorts of devices for some sort of disability that they have, I think it would be really inappropriate for our staff to have to ask them to report to the front desk when they arrive somewhere. I think that's really discriminatory, and I think it's unnecessary. I think it's unnecessary because I don't think that banning is going to stop those in our community that are going to be pursuing this sort of behaviour.
So we have to sort of balance, you know, people's right to Wear smart glasses if they have some disability that it helps with, and protecting people. And I think the staff have written here, our policy absolutely nails that, and that's quite comforting because some other councils I read about in my preparation for tonight's meeting, they had passed a ban and then they sort of doubled back and said, Oh no, you know, we won't do that. We'll just get people to report to the entry staff when they go somewhere. And I thought, wow, okay, and that's that sort of rabbit hole I don't want us to go down. I think we have to stick to what we can and tell people and advise people what we think is inappropriate, not based on a particular technology.
I think there's all sort of the other side of the litigation that I couldn't think of before was, you know, the manufacturers of this sort of technology, I wonder how they will view our signalling out their particular technology when there are other technologies that are able to do what we're claiming safe glasses, smart glasses would do. So, you know, I think, as Councillor Zamprogno said, this notice of motion comes from a good place. I just don't think that we're ready to make this sort of call at this time.
Thank you , Madam Mayor. Look, Councillor Zamprogno said that, you know, no one's been prosecuted for these smart glasses. I'll put a yet on that, because it's out there. We do have these people in our community who do take thousands of photos of kids, and I'm really aware of this myself, coming from a background and a couple of other issues that I've been involved with. I don't think we can just sit back and wait, because it's too serious on these. It's generally what happens. These people get them, and they get their jollies from putting me on the World Wide Web and all this sort of stuff. I think, as a council, we have a responsibility for these young people. We really do. And if our Councillor Wheeler's motion is not correct, well, we'll tidy it up as we go forward.
But we've just got to let them know that we're out there, we're watching. If you're doing the right thing, you've got nothing to worry about. And that's the way the law should work. If you play within the law, you've got nothing to worry about. It's only the ones that are stepping outside the rules that should be concerned, and that's what I believe Councillor Wheeler is directing with this motion, that we make them aware that we know what they are doing, and we'll lessen the impact, hopefully, on these young people that are—and it's mostly young people that are photographed by these odd pods. I do have other words for them. And perhaps we can protect them as they move forward. So, Councillor Wheeler, I thank you for bringing this forward.
It's a great idea, and let's get this up and happening. It mightn't be the best, but I believe it's something. We've got to start somewhere, and this is putting our best foot forward that we have at the moment. Thank you.
Thank you, Madam Mayor. I fully support this motion, and I'm not going to sugarcoat it. Anyone who walks around with glasses, whether they are secretly or undercover or in disguise or covertly filming other people are a creep. And we need to ban it. And I think it sends a really strong message from this council to say that we're not going to tolerate that in our community. And even further, if anyone walks around with those kind of glasses on in any spot where there's a child and they're filming children, lock them up. It's as simple as that. So I think that we need to be really firm and really strong that the safety and the privacy of our whole community, and specifically our vulnerable children, is our priority.
I get quite alarmed where society is heading with all of the technology that's happening. But I think for any individual who chooses to put a pair of these glasses on, walk out into a public space and film what's going on around them needs some help, quite frankly. And I'm really sorry, but I don't— please someone enlighten me. What disability requires you to walk around with sunglasses that can film other people? I'm really struggling to see what disability you might have that you require sunglasses that film strangers. That's really bizarre to me. So thank you, Councillor Wheeler, for bringing this. Protecting children is a huge priority, especially someone who practices in family law. It's what I do.
We need to make sure that we do everything and send the messages out there to our community that we won't tolerate these kind of creeps. So I think it's wonderful, and I'm fully supporting. Thank you. Thank you, Councillor McMahon. Councillor Veigel.
Yeah, thank you, Madam Mayor, and thank you, Councillor Wheeler, for the motion, because I'll be supporting it as well. Much of the comments have already been made by my colleagues here. It's interesting how the technology is changing. We don't say no to a seeing eye dog go into a library, and we can manage that. But that's not insidious like it's been pointed out with glasses. Have they got an LED on them? I wouldn't know. I don't—I wouldn't have a clue. I just think it's a moral question. You've got to put a line in the sand with this, and you're dead right. If somebody's wearing them and they're around public places, beaches, swimming pools, change rooms or whatever, it's a worry to me. We did have a case of work before I retired that some bloke was walking around with them.
They couldn't get the executive corporate to make a decision on it, so we made a local decision. If you want to wear them, you're not wearing them here. Okay, so again, thank you, Councillor Wheeler, and
I'll support the motion. Thank you, Councillor Veigel. I'll be supporting Councillor Wheeler's motion. I think this shows about how the advancements in technology are going forward so fast, and our laws are not necessarily keeping pace with them. And whereas they might be novel and fun for some people who are using them for whatever their design purpose is, the possibilities of misuse are quite extreme. And we know that we, you know, we have things like AI now that can manufacture people's voices and faces and present as being that person. You know, that's another area where we've got problems. But I think that where we're talking about the cheap available glasses that you can buy, you know, I don't know how much.
I think Councillor Wheeler told me they can be as cheap as— Twenty dollars or something like that. They're not going to be the ones that are the sophisticated ones that somebody with a visual impairment or some other need to be using a sophisticated pair of glasses would have to have. There's a big difference, I would think, between that. So I agree with, you know, again, this is an issue where we have to balance privacy with, you know, people's freedom to, you know, have some autonomy over what they're doing. But I think in this case, if we can play a role in further protection of vulnerable people in public spaces that we control, then I am really happy to support that. Our young people are under enough stress as it is with various, you know, things that they have to deal with.
If, as Councillor Ryan said, if we need to evolve this as developments change and technology changes, then we have the capacity to do that. So I will now pass to Councillor Wheeler for her right of
Reply. Thank you, and thank you everyone for what I think is a really interesting discussion. This is a difficult space, I think. We have seen in our lifetimes some of the most unprecedented advances in technology, and some of that is really difficult to manage and to regulate. I am amused at being accused of moral panic, given some of the things that were said about me on social media in the last six months. And I will point out that it's quite rare for the degenerate Greens, who are most often accused of being likely to end society as we know it, to be accused of moral panic. We're usually the ones causing it, so I'll wear that as a very short-lived badge of honour. Look , why would we wait for a prosecution to act?
That surely is shutting the door after the horse has bolted. This is really new technology. There's no legislation. The federal government has said that they're not going to introduce any legislation and told us to get on with doing that for our facilities. We are going to see a lot more of these. I worked in child protection in the late '90s, and I have to say the things that I saw there have so deeply scarred me at that time that I.. . It really did. I thought I was pretty savvy until I did that job. And, you know, it's sickening, absolutely sickening what is done with the images of children. It's why I never, ever post photos of children to social media, because it's horrifying, unimaginable, really.
This motion contains a clear carve-out for accessibility aids. It allows us to be careful around discrimination against people with disabilities, and I hope that consultation with the Access and Inclusion Committee can strengthen that and give us further advice on how we enact this. But what we are really trying to do here is give a clear signal to users of our facilities that we're aware of the misuse of this technology and that we will work to prevent it. The intention is to empower our staff while giving them enough leeway to allow accessibility aids to continue to be used to make people's lives easier and better. I think point three hopefully also allows the general manager enough leeway to apply that clause to council's facilities with the view of protecting workers as well as members of the public.
But I think this is a complex issue. It will continue to be an evolving space. I think instead of sticking to our knitting, we need to do our job as advocates for the community when the federal government doesn't appear to be keen on doing that, and nor does the lawmaking body, the New South Wales government. But also, we need to act to, where possible, keep our community safe. Thanks.
Councillors, before we move into confidential, I might propose a 10-minute break, but we might do the procedure about moving into confidential first, or when we come back in? When we come back in. All right, we'll take a 10-minute break. After that, we'll be doing confidential. Thank you Thank you, Councillors. We'll just resume. Could I have someone move that we go into confidential? Moved, Deputy Mayor, seconded Councillor Reardon. All those in favour? Unanimous. We will go into confidential session. Just wait.
15.1.1 — GM - 2027 Hawkesbury Australia Day Awards
Official meeting record
Council decision and source documents
Outcome: Carried
255 Resolution
The Director Corporate Services advised that whilst in closed session, the Council RESOLVED on the motion of Councillor Veigel, seconded by Councillor Reardon.
That Council adopt the confidential recommendation developed in Closed Session of Council in regard to the recipients of the 2027 Australia Day Awards.
Thank you. We're back on now, Councillors. Could the Councillors that had a declaration of interest to read, please do so onto the tape. Councillor McMahon.
Thank you, Madam Mayor. My declaration is in relation to item 15.1.1, the Australia Day Award nominations. I declare a pecuniary interest and left the room, as one of the nominees is associated with my employment. Thank you. Thank you, Councillor McMahon
Yeah, thanks, Madam Mayor. My declaration is the same, 15.1.1, Hawkesbury Australia Day Awards. I’ve run on my nomination form, and it’s a significant non-pecuniary interest. I say in the room, I’m not involved. He didn’t get elected,
I had a less significant non-pecuniary interest in 15.1.1, in that I knew a former member of a group that has been put forward for recognition, and the reason for no further action is that, being a former member, this person doesn’t benefit in any way from the group potentially progressing forward within the matter.
Laurie Mifsud(staff - Director Corporate Services)
You, Madam Mayor. In regard to item 15.1.1, 2027 Hawkesbury Australia Day Awards, whilst in closed session, Council resolved on the motion of Councillor Veigel, seconded by Councillor Reardon, that Council adopt the confidential recommendation developed in closed session of Council in regard to the recipients of the 2027 Australia Day Awards. Voting in favour of the recommendation were Councillors Djuric, Reardon, Veigel, Sheather, Zamprogno, Ryan, Wheeler, McMahon, Kotlash and Lyons-Buckett. Councillors Creed and Dogramaci were not present.
Before you close the meeting last year with the nominations we had, we were really scraped, as in previous years, to get nominations, and— The staff this year with the promotion in relation, we got 47 nominations for different categories. That's a big turnaround, and I think the staff should be congratulated for the effort they put into it.
On that note, Deputy Mayor, would you lead the singing to sing for... Thank you. Happy birthday to you. Happy birthday to you. Happy birthday to you. Thank you, everybody. Thank you, and good night.